The two efficiencies are not comparable directly
A gas boiler is rated on its gross or net efficiency, typically 88%–92% for a modern condensing unit, or 80%–85% for an older atmospheric boiler. A heat pump is rated on COP, typically 3.0–4.5. To compare them, put both on the same basis: energy delivered per unit of purchased energy.
| System | Efficiency | Purchased energy per 52.3 kWh of heat |
|---|---|---|
| Old atmospheric boiler | 0.75–0.82 | 64–70 kWh gas |
| Modern condensing boiler | 0.90–0.94 | 56–58 kWh gas |
| Air-source heat pump, 20 °C | COP 4.0 | 13.1 kWh electricity |
| Air-source heat pump, 7 °C | COP 3.3 | 15.8 kWh electricity |
| Air-source heat pump, −5 °C | COP 2.4 | 21.8 kWh electricity |
So a heat pump uses roughly a quarter of the purchased energy of a condensing boiler, in units. Whether that is cheaper depends entirely on the price ratio.
The price ratio decides everything
Let P_g be the gas price per kWh and P_e the electricity price per kWh. The heat pump is cheaper when:
P_e ÷ COP < P_g ÷ boiler efficiency
| Gas price | Boiler efficiency | Electricity price at which heat pump breaks even (COP 3.3) |
|---|---|---|
| USD 0.03/kWh | 0.90 | USD 0.110/kWh |
| USD 0.04/kWh | 0.90 | USD 0.147/kWh |
| USD 0.05/kWh | 0.90 | USD 0.183/kWh |
| USD 0.06/kWh | 0.90 | USD 0.220/kWh |
| USD 0.08/kWh | 0.90 | USD 0.293/kWh |
In most markets electricity costs three to four times as much as gas per kWh, and a COP of 3.3 gives a break-even ratio of about 3.0. That is why the answer is marginal in some countries and decisive in others.
A worked comparison
Assumptions: 10 m³ per day at ΔT 45 K, gas at USD 0.05/kWh, electricity at USD 0.12/kWh, condensing boiler at 92%, heat pump at COP 3.2 annual average.
| Item | Gas boiler | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| Heat required per day | 523 kWh | 523 kWh |
| Purchased energy per day | 568 kWh gas | 163 kWh electricity |
| Daily cost | USD 28.40 | USD 19.60 |
| Annual cost | USD 10,370 | USD 7,150 |
| Annual saving | — | USD 3,220 (31%) |
| Capital cost | Baseline | +USD 18,000–28,000 |
| Simple payback | — | 6–9 years |
A 31% saving and a six-to-nine-year payback is a real but unspectacular case. Change the electricity price to USD 0.08/kWh and the saving becomes 54% with a three-to-four-year payback. Change gas to USD 0.03/kWh and the heat pump loses.
Where the heat pump wins clearly
| Condition | Why |
|---|---|
| No gas grid available | LPG or diesel is far more expensive than gas |
| Gas price high, electricity moderate | Common in import-dependent markets |
| Cooling demand on the same site | Waste heat or shared infrastructure |
| Carbon or green certification target | Gas cannot decarbonise without biogas |
| Electrical capacity already available | Avoids a new gas connection |
| Urban air quality restrictions | Gas NOx limits tightening |
Where the boiler still wins
| Condition | Why |
|---|---|
| Very cheap gas, expensive electricity | The ratio is against the heat pump |
| Peak load only, a few hours a year | Capital cost cannot be recovered |
| Very high temperature process steam | Beyond heat pump range |
| Existing boiler in good condition, short remaining life of the building | Stranded asset risk |
| No space for outdoor units or storage | Physical constraint |
The honest answer for many retrofits is a hybrid: heat pumps for the base load, the boiler for peak and backup. That captures most of the saving with less capital and keeps resilience.
Hybrid sizing: how much heat pump?
| Heat pump share of annual demand | Saving achieved | Capital | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30% | About 25% | Low | Boiler still runs most of the winter |
| 50% | About 45% | Medium | Good balance for retrofits |
| 70% | About 65% | Medium-high | Boiler for cold snaps only |
| 100% | About 90% | High | Needs redundancy and low-temperature design |
The first 50% of the load is the cheapest to capture, because it runs the most hours. Beyond 70%, the marginal cost rises steeply as the plant has to cover the coldest hours.
Carbon comparison
| Source | CO₂ per kWh heat | Relative |
|---|---|---|
| Gas boiler at 92% | 0.21 kg | 100% |
| Heat pump COP 3.3, grid 0.55 kg/kWh | 0.17 kg | 79% |
| Heat pump COP 3.3, grid 0.30 kg/kWh | 0.09 kg | 43% |
| Heat pump COP 4.0, grid 0.20 kg/kWh | 0.05 kg | 24% |
On a coal-heavy grid the heat pump’s carbon advantage is modest; on a cleaner grid it is large. Because grids are decarbonising, the heat pump’s advantage improves over its life, while the boiler’s does not.
Practical differences beyond cost
| Factor | Gas boiler | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| Plant room | Gas train, flue, ventilation, leak detection | Outdoor units, storage, no flue |
| Maintenance | Annual service, gas safety check | Coil cleaning, refrigerant check |
| Life | 12–20 years | 15–20 years |
| Noise | Burner and flue | Fan and compressor |
| Response | Fast | Slower, needs storage |
| Safety | Combustion, CO risk | Refrigerant, electrical |
| Regulation | Increasingly restricted | Favored in new build |
Refitting a boiler plant: the constraints that decide
| Constraint | Check before committing |
|---|---|
| Flow temperature | Existing radiators may need 70–80 °C; heat pump prefers 55 |
| Storage | Boiler systems often have little; heat pump needs more |
| Electrical supply | Typically needs a significant upgrade |
| Space | Outdoor units and tanks need room the boiler did not |
| Flue and gas route | Can be removed, which frees plant room space |
The flow temperature is the constraint that kills most retrofits. A boiler system designed for 80/60 °C cannot simply be fed at 55 °C; the emitters have to be enlarged or the heat pump has to be a high-temperature model with a lower COP.
Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. builds the comparison around the site’s actual gas and electricity tariffs and the existing boiler’s measured efficiency, rather than a generic ratio, because a 10% error in the gas price changes the conclusion. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280
Questions from retrofit projects
Is a heat pump always cheaper to run than a gas boiler?
No. It depends on the price ratio. With gas at USD 0.03/kWh and electricity at USD 0.15/kWh, a boiler at 92% is cheaper than a heat pump at COP 3.3. Do the arithmetic before promising a saving.
What COP should I use in the calculation?
The seasonal average at the actual water temperature, not the rated COP at 7 °C. For 60 °C storage in a cold climate, 2.5–3.0 is realistic; for 45 °C in a mild climate, 3.5–4.0.
Can I keep the boiler as backup and still claim the saving?
Yes, and it is the usual approach. Model the hybrid: the saving is proportional to the share of load the heat pump carries, not to its rated capacity.
How long does a boiler-to-heat-pump conversion take?
Four to ten weeks for a commercial plant, including electrical upgrade and storage. The electrical work is often the critical path, not the heat pump.
Do I need to change the radiators?
If the existing system runs at 80/60 °C, probably yes, or add surface area. If it runs at 60/45 °C, the heat pump can usually match it. Measure the actual flow temperature before deciding.
What about NOx and air quality rules?
Many cities now limit NOx from gas boilers, and some restrict new gas connections entirely. Check the local rules; they can make the decision for you regardless of price.
Related reading
- Heat pump versus electric water heater
- Factory dormitory hot water design
- Air-source heat pump water heater product page
- Replacing a steam boiler with a high-temperature heat pump