The plant and the problem
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Process | Fine chemical synthesis, solvent-based, eight jacketed reactors |
| Batch size | 2–12 m³, 4–8 batches a day |
| Cooling demand | Jacket at −8 °C to +5 °C, peak 320 kW, sustained 190 kW |
| Existing plant | 1 × 250 kW air-cooled chiller, R22, installed 2011, inside Zone 2 |
| Failure | Compressor motor not Ex-rated; audit finding, plus 6 lost batches in 2022 from trips |
| Site constraint | No spare plant room; only a covered compound outside the classified area |
The audit finding was specific: the compressor and fan motors were standard IP54 machines inside a Zone 2 boundary, and the control panel had no Ex protection. The plant had two options — convert the machine, which was not economic on a 12-year-old unit with R22, or relocate the cooling plant outside the zone and extend the secondary loop.
The arrangement chosen
The plant chose relocation. Two 180 kW low-temperature screw chillers were installed in a covered compound 40 m from the reactor building, outside the classified boundary, with a 35% ethylene glycol secondary loop to the jackets and a 6 m³ buffer tank in the loop.
| Design decision | Choice | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Chiller location | Outside the Zone 2 boundary, under a canopy | Avoids Ex rating on the largest electrical load |
| Motors | Ex d IIB T4 as standard on this model | Kept for future re-siting flexibility |
| Refrigerant | R134a | Lower pressure, GWP 1,430, serviceable locally |
| Secondary coolant | 35% ethylene glycol, −20 °C freeze point | −8 °C jacket with 5 K approach margin |
| Leaving coolant temperature | −12 °C | Jacket −8 °C with 4 K approach |
| Buffer | 6 m³ insulated, baffled | Absorbs a 320 kW peak for 20 minutes |
| Units | 2 × 180 kW, cascade, lead rotation weekly | 60% capacity on one unit, full N+1 on jacket duty |
| Control link | Modbus to the reactor DCS, remote setpoint | Jacket temperature follows the batch recipe |
| Pipework | DN100 carbon steel, insulated, traced | 40 m run, 1.2 m/s at design flow |
The pipe run was the main cost of the relocation: 80 m of insulated DN100 supply and return, a 15 kW secondary pump, and a plate exchanger to keep the chiller loop clean. That package came to about 18% of the project cost, and it removed the safety finding permanently.
Commissioning data
Commissioning was done in July, with 34 °C ambient and the plant at normal production. The readings below are from the commissioning sheet, taken at steady state after 30 minutes at full load on one unit.
| Parameter | Design | Measured | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leaving coolant temperature | −12 °C | −12.3 °C | Within tolerance |
| Return coolant temperature | −7 °C | −6.9 °C | — |
| Coolant flow | 31 m³/h | 32.4 m³/h | +4.5% |
| Cooling capacity | 180 kW | 176 kW | 98% of nominal, glycol derate included |
| Power input | 52 kW | 51.6 kW | — |
| COP at site conditions | 3.40 | 3.41 | Meets specification |
| Condensing approach | 3 K | 2.6 K | Clean condenser |
| Jacket temperature stability | ±1.5 K | ±0.9 K | Better than required |
| Noise at 1 m | 75 dB(A) | 73 dB(A) | Within plant limit |
| Vibration, compressor | 4.5 mm/s | 3.1 mm/s | Acceptable |
The capacity figure is worth noting: 176 kW measured against 180 kW nominal, with the glycol derate already applied in the selection. A machine selected on a water-rated 180 kW would have delivered about 158 kW on 35% glycol, and the plant would have been 12% short on the design day.
What changed in operation
| Metric | Before (2022) | After (2024) | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lost batches from cooling trips | 6 | 0 | Production records |
| Cooling energy | about 268,000 kWh | about 216,000 kWh | Metered, 12 months |
| Cost at 0.75 CNY/kWh | 201,000 CNY | 162,000 CNY | — |
| Batch cooling time, 8 m³ | 6.5 h average | 5.2 h average | Recipe records |
| Maintenance interventions | 9 | 3 | Service log |
The energy reduction came from three sources, none of them exotic: the new machines run at COP 3.41 against 2.4 on the old unit at the same conditions, the buffer tank stops short cycling, and the secondary loop lets the chiller run at a steady load instead of following every jacket demand. The shorter batch time came from the higher coolant flow and the stable jacket temperature — 5.2 hours instead of 6.5 is a 20% increase in reactor throughput, which was worth more than the energy saving.
Three lessons for similar projects
1. Relocate before you specify Ex. An Ex-rated chiller carries a 40%–70% premium and every maintenance task inside the zone needs a permit. Where the layout allows 30–50 m of pipe, the secondary loop is cheaper over the life of the plant and removes the safety finding completely.
2. Put the glycol derate in the selection, not in the commissioning report. The difference between water-rated and glycol-rated capacity at −12 °C is 12%–15%. Discovering it during commissioning means either a third unit or an acceptance argument.
3. Size the buffer on the exotherm, not on the average. The 6 m³ tank absorbs 320 kW for 20 minutes with a 4.5 K rise, which covers the addition phase of the largest batch. Without it, the chiller would need to be 70% larger, and would then run at 20% load for the rest of the day.
Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. supplied the two 180 kW low-temperature screw chillers, the glycol loop design and the commissioning support for this project, with the capacity table stated at −12 °C on 35% glycol rather than at water conditions. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280
Questions about this type of project
Does the chiller itself need to be explosion-proof if it is outside the zone?
No. The classification applies to the area, not the machine. Place the chiller outside the boundary and the standard industrial machine is compliant — but confirm the boundary on the area classification drawing, not on a site walk.
How far can the chiller be from the reactors?
Up to about 100 m is practical with a correctly sized secondary pump and insulated pipes; beyond that, pump head and heat gain dominate. This project used 40 m with a 15 kW pump and 40 mm insulation.
What glycol concentration should be used?
Enough to keep the freeze point 5–8 K below the lowest coolant temperature. For −12 °C leaving coolant, 35% ethylene glycol (freeze −20 °C) is appropriate; 30% would freeze at −15 °C, which is too close.
How is the Ex rating verified?
By certificate: the motor nameplate should carry Ex d IIB T4 (or the class required by the zone), with a certificate number traceable to the notified body. A supplier’s statement is not a certificate.
What does the secondary loop add to the pumping cost?
For this project, a 15 kW secondary pump against 176 kW of cooling is about 8.5% of the chiller input, which the measured system COP already includes. The pipe heat gain over 40 m of insulated DN100 is roughly 1.5 kW, or under 1% of capacity.
Can the existing R22 machine be converted?
Technically sometimes, economically rarely. A retrofit to R134a or R513A needs a new expansion device, oil change and often a new compressor, on a shell that is already 12 years old — and it does not solve the Ex finding.
Related reading
- Explosion-proof chillers for hazardous areas
- Reactor cooling chiller selection
- Water chiller product page
- Engineering case studies