The capacity ranges overlap more than the brochures suggest
| Compressor | Typical cooling capacity | Practical range | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scroll | 20–200 kW | Up to 4 in tandem | Small and modular |
| Screw | 150–1,500 kW | Single or twin rotor | Widest commercial range |
| Centrifugal | 500–5,000 kW | Single or two stage | Large plant |
| Magnetic bearing centrifugal | 300–3,000 kW | Oil-free | Growing share |
A 600 kW project can use a screw or a small centrifugal, and both will be offered. The decision then turns on part-load efficiency, maintenance and price.
Full-load efficiency
| Machine | COP at AHRI conditions | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Screw, water-cooled | 5.0–5.8 | Mature, robust |
| Screw, air-cooled | 3.0–3.4 | Condenser fan power included |
| Centrifugal, water-cooled | 5.8–6.5 | Better at large sizes |
| Magnetic bearing centrifugal | 6.2–7.0 | Highest at full load |
The centrifugal advantage grows with size: at 500 kW the gap is small, at 2,000 kW it is decisive. Below 400 kW, centrifugal machines are rarely economic.
Part-load efficiency is where the money is
Most chillers run below 60% load for most of the year. IPLV weights the four rating points (100%, 75%, 50%, 25%) and is a better indicator of annual energy than COP.
| Machine | COP | IPLV | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Screw, fixed speed | 5.4 | 5.9 | 1.09 |
| Screw with VSD | 5.4 | 6.6 | 1.22 |
| Centrifugal, fixed speed | 6.2 | 6.4 | 1.03 |
| Centrifugal with VSD | 6.2 | 7.2 | 1.16 |
| Magnetic bearing with VSD | 6.6 | 7.6 | 1.15 |
A fixed-speed centrifugal has excellent full-load efficiency but poor part-load behavior: at 40% load it may be worse than a screw. A VSD centrifugal is efficient across the range, which is why VSD has become standard on large machines.
Surge: the centrifugal constraint
A centrifugal compressor surges when the flow is too low for the pressure ratio — the flow reverses momentarily, the machine makes a characteristic noise and the discharge temperature rises.
| Condition | Risk | Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Below 20%–30% load | High | Hot gas bypass, or a second smaller machine |
| High condensing pressure | High | Better tower performance, VSD |
| Rapid load change | Moderate | Gradual staging, VSD |
| Low chilled water flow | High | Minimum flow bypass |
Screw compressors do not surge. They unload by sliding the rotor, and they tolerate low load far better. For a building that runs at 15% load at night, that is a real advantage.
Oil: the maintenance difference
| Item | Screw | Centrifugal (oil-fed) | Magnetic bearing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oil charge | 50–200 L | 100–400 L | None |
| Oil change | 3–5 years, by analysis | 3–5 years | None |
| Oil cooler | Required | Required | None |
| Oil pressure protection | Yes | Yes | Not applicable |
| Bearing wear | Rolling or journal | Journal | Levitated |
| Maintenance skill | Standard | Specialist | Specialist |
Magnetic bearing machines remove the oil system entirely, which reduces maintenance and eliminates oil carry-over into the refrigerant. The trade-off is a more complex control system and a higher capital cost.
Practical selection matrix
| Situation | Recommendation | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 200–500 kW, water-cooled | Screw | Lowest cost per kW, robust |
| 200–500 kW, air-cooled | Screw | Scroll above 150 kW gets complex |
| 500–1,000 kW, variable load | Screw with VSD or small centrifugal | Part-load matters |
| 1,000–3,000 kW, base load | Centrifugal with VSD | Efficiency at scale |
| Very low night load | Screw, or a small dedicated machine | Avoid surge |
| No oil maintenance capability | Magnetic bearing | Oil-free |
| Tight plant room | Centrifugal (compact per kW) | Higher kW/m² |
| Fast delivery required | Screw | Wider availability |
Redundancy and staging
| Configuration | Advantage | Disadvantage |
|---|---|---|
| 3 × 50% screw | Good part load, N+1 | Three machines to maintain |
| 2 × 50% centrifugal | Fewer machines | Poor part load below 40% |
| 1 large + 1 small | Covers night load | Two different machines |
| 4 × 25% modular | Excellent staging | More footprint and piping |
For a hotel or an office that runs 24 hours, a large-plus-small arrangement often beats two equal machines: the small unit handles the night load without surging, and the large one handles the afternoon peak efficiently.
Cost comparison
| Item | Screw 600 kW | Centrifugal 600 kW |
|---|---|---|
| Chiller capital | Baseline | +10%–25% |
| Plant room | Slightly larger | Compact |
| Electrical | Similar | Higher starting current, VSD needed |
| Maintenance | Lower skill requirement | Specialist |
| Energy at high hours | Baseline | 5%–10% lower |
| Energy at low load | Better without VSD | Better with VSD |
At 600 kW with 4,000 hours a year, the centrifugal’s energy advantage often repays its premium in four to six years. At 1,500 hours a year, it does not.
Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. offers screw and centrifugal ranges and provides the part-load model for the building’s own load duration curve, so the comparison is made on annual energy rather than on nominal COP. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280
Questions from designers
Which is more reliable?
Both are mature. Screw machines tolerate abuse better and are simpler to service; centrifugal machines have fewer moving parts in the compressor but need surge protection and, in oil-fed designs, careful oil management.
Can a centrifugal run at 10% load?
Most cannot without hot gas bypass, which wastes energy. Below 20%–30%, a smaller machine or a screw is the better answer.
Is a magnetic bearing chiller worth the premium?
Where maintenance access is difficult, where oil contamination is unacceptable, or where part-load efficiency is the priority. The premium is typically 15%–30% and is recovered through efficiency and maintenance.
How does refrigerant choice affect the decision?
Large centrifugal machines historically used low-pressure refrigerants; modern designs use HFCs or HFOs with different charge sizes and safety classifications. Check the charge against local refrigerant regulations.
What about VSD on a screw?
It improves part-load performance significantly and is now common. The saving is largest on machines that run below 70% load for long periods.
How long does each last?
Both reach 15–25 years with maintenance. Centrifugal machines are often overhauled at 10–12 years; screw compressors may need a replacement at 10–15 years depending on hours.
Related reading
- Air-cooled versus water-cooled chillers
- How to size a water chiller
- Water chiller product page
- Chillers for data centers