Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Knowledge

Screw versus Centrifugal Chillers: Selection by Capacity and Load Profile

The capacity ranges overlap more than the brochures suggest

Compressor Typical cooling capacity Practical range Notes
Scroll 20–200 kW Up to 4 in tandem Small and modular
Screw 150–1,500 kW Single or twin rotor Widest commercial range
Centrifugal 500–5,000 kW Single or two stage Large plant
Magnetic bearing centrifugal 300–3,000 kW Oil-free Growing share

A 600 kW project can use a screw or a small centrifugal, and both will be offered. The decision then turns on part-load efficiency, maintenance and price.

Full-load efficiency

Machine COP at AHRI conditions Comment
Screw, water-cooled 5.0–5.8 Mature, robust
Screw, air-cooled 3.0–3.4 Condenser fan power included
Centrifugal, water-cooled 5.8–6.5 Better at large sizes
Magnetic bearing centrifugal 6.2–7.0 Highest at full load

The centrifugal advantage grows with size: at 500 kW the gap is small, at 2,000 kW it is decisive. Below 400 kW, centrifugal machines are rarely economic.

Part-load efficiency is where the money is

Most chillers run below 60% load for most of the year. IPLV weights the four rating points (100%, 75%, 50%, 25%) and is a better indicator of annual energy than COP.

Machine COP IPLV Ratio
Screw, fixed speed 5.4 5.9 1.09
Screw with VSD 5.4 6.6 1.22
Centrifugal, fixed speed 6.2 6.4 1.03
Centrifugal with VSD 6.2 7.2 1.16
Magnetic bearing with VSD 6.6 7.6 1.15

A fixed-speed centrifugal has excellent full-load efficiency but poor part-load behavior: at 40% load it may be worse than a screw. A VSD centrifugal is efficient across the range, which is why VSD has become standard on large machines.

Surge: the centrifugal constraint

A centrifugal compressor surges when the flow is too low for the pressure ratio — the flow reverses momentarily, the machine makes a characteristic noise and the discharge temperature rises.

Condition Risk Measure
Below 20%–30% load High Hot gas bypass, or a second smaller machine
High condensing pressure High Better tower performance, VSD
Rapid load change Moderate Gradual staging, VSD
Low chilled water flow High Minimum flow bypass

Screw compressors do not surge. They unload by sliding the rotor, and they tolerate low load far better. For a building that runs at 15% load at night, that is a real advantage.

Oil: the maintenance difference

Item Screw Centrifugal (oil-fed) Magnetic bearing
Oil charge 50–200 L 100–400 L None
Oil change 3–5 years, by analysis 3–5 years None
Oil cooler Required Required None
Oil pressure protection Yes Yes Not applicable
Bearing wear Rolling or journal Journal Levitated
Maintenance skill Standard Specialist Specialist

Magnetic bearing machines remove the oil system entirely, which reduces maintenance and eliminates oil carry-over into the refrigerant. The trade-off is a more complex control system and a higher capital cost.

Practical selection matrix

Situation Recommendation Reason
200–500 kW, water-cooled Screw Lowest cost per kW, robust
200–500 kW, air-cooled Screw Scroll above 150 kW gets complex
500–1,000 kW, variable load Screw with VSD or small centrifugal Part-load matters
1,000–3,000 kW, base load Centrifugal with VSD Efficiency at scale
Very low night load Screw, or a small dedicated machine Avoid surge
No oil maintenance capability Magnetic bearing Oil-free
Tight plant room Centrifugal (compact per kW) Higher kW/m²
Fast delivery required Screw Wider availability

Redundancy and staging

Configuration Advantage Disadvantage
3 × 50% screw Good part load, N+1 Three machines to maintain
2 × 50% centrifugal Fewer machines Poor part load below 40%
1 large + 1 small Covers night load Two different machines
4 × 25% modular Excellent staging More footprint and piping

For a hotel or an office that runs 24 hours, a large-plus-small arrangement often beats two equal machines: the small unit handles the night load without surging, and the large one handles the afternoon peak efficiently.

Cost comparison

Item Screw 600 kW Centrifugal 600 kW
Chiller capital Baseline +10%–25%
Plant room Slightly larger Compact
Electrical Similar Higher starting current, VSD needed
Maintenance Lower skill requirement Specialist
Energy at high hours Baseline 5%–10% lower
Energy at low load Better without VSD Better with VSD

At 600 kW with 4,000 hours a year, the centrifugal’s energy advantage often repays its premium in four to six years. At 1,500 hours a year, it does not.

Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. offers screw and centrifugal ranges and provides the part-load model for the building’s own load duration curve, so the comparison is made on annual energy rather than on nominal COP. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280

Questions from designers

Which is more reliable?

Both are mature. Screw machines tolerate abuse better and are simpler to service; centrifugal machines have fewer moving parts in the compressor but need surge protection and, in oil-fed designs, careful oil management.

Can a centrifugal run at 10% load?

Most cannot without hot gas bypass, which wastes energy. Below 20%–30%, a smaller machine or a screw is the better answer.

Is a magnetic bearing chiller worth the premium?

Where maintenance access is difficult, where oil contamination is unacceptable, or where part-load efficiency is the priority. The premium is typically 15%–30% and is recovered through efficiency and maintenance.

How does refrigerant choice affect the decision?

Large centrifugal machines historically used low-pressure refrigerants; modern designs use HFCs or HFOs with different charge sizes and safety classifications. Check the charge against local refrigerant regulations.

What about VSD on a screw?

It improves part-load performance significantly and is now common. The saving is largest on machines that run below 70% load for long periods.

How long does each last?

Both reach 15–25 years with maintenance. Centrifugal machines are often overhauled at 10–12 years; screw compressors may need a replacement at 10–15 years depending on hours.

Related reading

Frequently asked questions