The physics, in one line
An electric resistance heater converts one unit of electricity into at most one unit of heat. A heat pump moves heat from the air, so one unit of electricity delivers three to four units of heat. That is the whole comparison; everything else is arithmetic.
| Heater type | Efficiency | Energy to heat 1 m³ by 45 K |
|---|---|---|
| Electric resistance | 0.95–1.00 | 52–55 kWh |
| Air-source heat pump, mild ambient | COP 3.5–4.5 | 12–15 kWh |
| Air-source heat pump, cold ambient | COP 2.0–2.5 | 21–26 kWh |
| Immersion in a tank | 1.00 | 52 kWh |
The baseline figure: 1,000 kg × 4.186 kJ/kg·K × 45 K ÷ 3,600 = 52.3 kWh of heat. Divide by the efficiency to get the electricity.
Running cost, with transparent assumptions
The numbers below use example tariffs. Substitute your own; the ratio is what matters.
| Item | Electric resistance | Heat pump (COP 3.5) |
|---|---|---|
| Electricity per m³ | 53.4 kWh | 14.9 kWh |
| Tariff (example) | USD 0.12/kWh | USD 0.12/kWh |
| Cost per m³ | USD 6.41 | USD 1.79 |
| Annual at 10 m³/day | USD 23,400 | USD 6,530 |
| Annual saving | — | USD 16,870 |
At 10 m³ per day the saving is around USD 16,000 a year in this example. A hotel or dormitory at 50 m³ per day saves five times that.
| Daily demand | Electric annual cost | Heat pump annual cost | Saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 m³ | USD 4,680 | USD 1,306 | USD 3,374 |
| 5 m³ | USD 11,700 | USD 3,265 | USD 8,435 |
| 10 m³ | USD 23,400 | USD 6,530 | USD 16,870 |
| 30 m³ | USD 70,200 | USD 19,590 | USD 50,610 |
Capital cost and payback
A heat pump system costs more than a resistance heater, mostly because of the compressor, the larger tank and the controls.
| System | Relative capital cost | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance tanks | 1.0 | Tank, elements, simple control |
| Small heat pump, 5–15 kW | 2.0–2.8 | Unit, tank, pump, installation |
| Commercial heat pump, 30–100 kW | 2.5–3.5 | Bank of units, storage, controls |
| Heat pump plus solar preheat | 3.5–4.5 | Adds collectors and controls |
| Daily demand | Extra capital | Annual saving | Simple payback |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 m³ | USD 3,000–5,000 | USD 3,374 | 1–1.5 years |
| 5 m³ | USD 8,000–12,000 | USD 8,435 | 1–1.5 years |
| 10 m³ | USD 15,000–25,000 | USD 16,870 | 1–1.5 years |
| 30 m³ | USD 45,000–70,000 | USD 50,610 | 1–1.4 years |
The payback is short because resistance heating is so expensive to run. Projects that replace resistance heating with heat pumps usually pay back within two years, which is why this is the easiest retrofit to justify.
Where a resistance heater still makes sense
| Situation | Why resistance is acceptable |
|---|---|
| Very small demand, under 0.5 m³/day | Capital cost dominates; heat pump never pays back |
| Backup or top-up only | Used a few hours a year |
| Extremely tight space | No room for an outdoor unit |
| Intermittent use, holiday lets | Heat pump standing losses and controls add complexity |
| Process requiring instant very high temperature | Beyond heat pump range |
The mistake is not choosing resistance for a small backup; it is choosing it for a 20 m³/day hotel because the capital budget was tight.
The tank is part of the comparison
| Factor | Resistance | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| Tank volume per m³ daily demand | 0.3–0.5 | 0.4–0.7 |
| Recovery time | Fast, limited by element power | Slower, limited by compressor |
| Stratification | Poor at high element power | Good, low flow |
| Standing loss | Similar | Similar |
A heat pump heats more slowly, so it needs more storage for the same peak. The tank cost is part of the heat pump’s capital premium and should be in the comparison, not hidden in a separate line.
Cold climate derating
| Ambient | COP | Electricity per m³ | Cost increase vs 20 °C |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 °C | 4.0 | 13.1 kWh | — |
| 7 °C | 3.3 | 15.8 kWh | +21% |
| −5 °C | 2.4 | 21.8 kWh | +66% |
| −15 °C | 1.9 | 27.5 kWh | +110% |
Even at −15 °C the heat pump uses about half the electricity of a resistance heater. The economics weaken but do not reverse. In a climate with long cold winters, choose a low-temperature model and keep a resistance top-up for the coldest weeks.
Carbon, briefly
| Source | CO₂ per kWh heat |
|---|---|
| Resistance, grid at 0.55 kg/kWh | 0.58 kg |
| Heat pump COP 3.5, same grid | 0.16 kg |
| Heat pump COP 3.5, grid at 0.30 kg/kWh | 0.09 kg |
The heat pump cuts emissions by roughly 70% on a typical grid, and more as the grid decarbonises. For a building with a green certification target, that is often worth as much as the energy saving.
Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. provides the comparison sheet with the customer’s own tariff and daily demand entered, so the payback is calculated on their numbers rather than on a generic example. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280
Questions from buyers
How long does a heat pump last compared with a resistance heater?
Fifteen to twenty years for a commercial heat pump with maintenance; ten to fifteen for a resistance tank, limited by the elements and the lining. The heat pump’s compressor is the life-limiting item.
Is the saving really 70%?
In energy terms, yes, at COP 3.5. In cost terms it depends on the tariff: if electricity is cheap, the saving in money is smaller but the percentage is similar. The 70% figure refers to electricity consumption, not to the bill.
Can I keep my existing tank?
Sometimes. If the tank has a coil sized for a heat pump and is in good condition, it can be reused. A tank designed for a 6 kW element may not transfer 30 kW from a heat pump, so check the coil rating.
What if the building has a three-phase supply?
Most commercial heat pumps need three-phase 380–415 V. If only single-phase is available, the practical limit is 3–5 kW per unit, which suits small buildings only.
Do heat pumps work in very cold places?
Yes, with a low-temperature model, but capacity and COP fall. Below about −15 °C, many designs use a hybrid with a resistance or boiler top-up rather than oversizing the heat pump.
Which is quieter?
A heat pump has a fan and a compressor, typically 58–65 dB(A) at 1 m, which is louder than a resistance tank (silent). Siting and isolation matter; a resistance heater inside the bathroom is not a fair comparison for noise.
Related reading
- Heat pump versus gas boiler for hot water
- How to size an air-source heat pump water heater
- Air-source heat pump water heater product page