1. The batch profile, not the average load
A 5 m³ reactor charged at 25 °C and cooled to 5 °C over four hours looks like a modest load:
Q = 5,000 kg × 3.8 kJ/(kg·K) × 20 K ÷ 14,400 s = 26.4 kW
But sensible cooling of the batch is rarely the governing case. The reaction itself releases heat, and the release rate is not constant. For many organic reactions the peak heat release is three to five times the average over the addition period, and it lasts minutes, not hours. A chiller sized on 26.4 kW will be overwhelmed at the moment the initiator is charged.
| Load case | Duration | Typical magnitude | Governs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sensible pre-cool | 2–6 h | 20–40 kW for a 5 m³ batch | Chiller nominal capacity |
| Reaction heat release, average | 1–4 h | 1.5–3 × sensible | Chiller + buffer |
| Reaction heat release, peak | 5–20 min | 3–5 × sensible | Buffer volume, jacket area |
| Post-reaction hold | 6–24 h | 10%–20% of sensible | Part-load stability |
| Cleaning and turnaround | 1–2 h | 30–50 kW | Recovery time |
The correct method is to size the chiller on the sustained load and the buffer tank on the peak. A 30 kW chiller with a 3 m³ buffer at −5 °C can absorb a 90 kW peak for twenty minutes while the tank rises 4 K, then recover over the next two hours. That is cheaper and more stable than a 90 kW chiller running at 15% load for the rest of the week.
2. Coolant temperature and glycol selection
Reactor jackets commonly run at −10 °C to +5 °C, which forces a secondary coolant. Below 0 °C the choice is ethylene glycol, propylene glycol or a brine.
| Coolant | Concentration | Freeze point | Viscosity penalty | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water | — | 0 °C | None | Only above 5 °C |
| Ethylene glycol | 30% | −15 °C | +25% pump power | Highest heat transfer of the glycols |
| Ethylene glycol | 40% | −24 °C | +45% pump power | Common for −15 °C duty |
| Propylene glycol | 30% | −13 °C | +35% pump power | Low toxicity, food and pharma |
| Propylene glycol | 40% | −21 °C | +60% pump power | — |
| Calcium chloride brine | 25% | −20 °C | +20% | Corrosive, needs inhibitors |
Two consequences follow. First, the chiller’s evaporator must be rated for the mixture, not for water: the heat transfer coefficient falls and the flow rises, so a machine selected for water duty at the same nominal capacity will not deliver it on 40% glycol. Second, pump power rises with viscosity, and a plant designed without that allowance runs short on flow in winter — which reads on site as “the chiller is not cooling”.
3. Buffer tank: the cheapest safety system on the plant
The buffer tank does three jobs: it absorbs the exotherm peak, it gives the chiller a stable return temperature so it does not short-cycle, and it holds enough volume that a chiller trip does not immediately stop the batch.
| Peak heat release | Buffer at ΔT 4 K | Buffer at ΔT 8 K | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60 kW for 15 min | 3.2 m³ | 1.6 m³ | 15 min × 60 kW = 15 kWh |
| 90 kW for 20 min | 4.8 m³ | 2.4 m³ | Larger ΔT halves the tank |
| 150 kW for 10 min | 5.4 m³ | 2.7 m³ | Insulate well; 150 kW peak |
The tank should be stratified or fitted with a baffle, insulated to at least 50 mm, and connected so the chiller sees the coldest layer. A tank plumbed as a simple tee into the return line will mix and deliver half its nominal capacity.
4. Wetted materials and fouling
The process side is the plant’s problem; the chiller side is a water-quality problem that the plant usually ignores.
| Parameter | Limit for standard shell-and-tube | Action if exceeded |
|---|---|---|
| Chloride | 200 mg/L | 316L tubes, or plate exchanger with titanium |
| Hardness | 200 mg/L as CaCO₃ | Softener upstream |
| Suspended solids | 30 mg/L | Filtration, 100 µm |
| pH | 6.5–8.5 | Corrosion inhibitor, material review |
| Conductivity | 500 µS/cm | Closed loop with DI make-up |
Where the jacket circuit is closed and treated, the chiller sees clean glycol and lasts. Where it is fed with raw cooling water and drained, the tubes scale within a season and the approach temperature climbs. Put a plate-and-frame exchanger between the process loop and the chiller loop when the process fluid is aggressive, and keep the chiller on a clean closed circuit — it costs 8%–12% of the plant and removes most corrosion risk.
5. Hazardous area and explosion protection
Reactors handling solvents sit in classified zones, and the chiller is invariably the largest electrical load nearby. The practical rule is to place the chiller outside the classified area and run the coolant pipes in — this avoids paying for an explosion-proof machine and simplifies maintenance.
Where the chiller must sit inside the zone, the classification drives the specification:
| Zone | Typical requirement | Cost premium |
|---|---|---|
| Zone 2 | Ex d or Ex e motors, spark-free fans, IP54 panel | 20%–35% |
| Zone 1 | Ex d IIB T4 motors, intrinsically safe controls, no hot surfaces above T-class | 40%–70% |
| Dust, Zone 21/22 | Ex t enclosure, surface temperature control | 25%–40% |
Explosion protection applies to the electrical components, not to the refrigerant circuit — but the refrigerant charge and the ventilation of the plant room still matter, and a leak in a confined space displaces oxygen. If the machine is in a basement, specify leak detection and mechanical ventilation.
A worked selection
A 5 m³ reactor, solvent process, 20 K pre-cool over 4 hours, peak heat release 3.5 × average, jacket at −8 °C, plant in Zone 2.
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Sensible load | 5,000 × 3.8 × 20 ÷ 14,400 | 26.4 kW |
| Average reaction load | 2.2 × sensible | 58 kW |
| Peak reaction load | 3.5 × average, 15 min | 203 kW peak, 48 kWh |
| Coolant | 35% ethylene glycol, freeze −20 °C | Evaporating −12 °C, leaving −8 °C |
| Chiller | Sustained 58 kW at −8 °C, plus 15% margin | 65 kW low-temperature unit |
| Buffer | 48 kWh over ΔT 6 K | 6.9 m³, specify 7 m³ |
| Evaporator | Rated for 35% glycol, not water | Capacity derate 12% already applied |
Note the last row. A 65 kW machine rated on water at 7 °C delivers about 57 kW on 35% glycol at −8 °C. Selecting it without the derate is the most common error in reactor cooling, and it shows up as a batch that takes six hours instead of four.
Control: the detail that decides product quality
Reactor temperature control needs the chiller to follow a jacket setpoint that moves during the batch, not a fixed leaving water temperature. Three features make that possible:
- Stepless capacity control down to 20%–25%, so the chiller can hold a jacket temperature while the reaction is at low load.
- Remote setpoint from the reactor control system, over Modbus or a 4–20 mA signal.
- Hot gas bypass or a three-way mixing valve, so the chiller keeps running when the jacket demand falls to zero without cycling.
A chiller with on/off control only will oscillate the jacket temperature by 3–5 K, which in a crystallisation or a polymerisation step is the difference between two product grades.
Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. supplies low-temperature screw chillers rated on glycol from −25 °C to +5 °C, with Ex d motor options and Modbus remote setpoint, and will state the glycol derate on the datasheet rather than leaving it to the buyer. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280
Questions from process engineers
Can I use the existing comfort-cooling chiller for reactor cooling?
Only if its evaporator is rated for the glycol and the lower temperature. A comfort chiller at 7 °C leaving water will trip on low pressure at −8 °C, and its capacity at that condition is 35%–45% of nominal, not 90%.
How big a buffer tank do I need?
Size it on the peak heat release multiplied by its duration, divided by the permitted temperature rise: kWh ÷ (1.163 × ΔT) gives m³. Most plants land between 1.5 and 7 m³ for reactors of 3–10 m³.
Should the chiller be inside or outside the classified area?
Outside, wherever the layout allows. Renting a few meters of pipe is far cheaper than an Ex-rated machine, and maintenance on an Ex unit requires a permit every time a panel is opened.
What leaving temperature should I specify?
Three to five kelvin below the coldest jacket temperature you need, no more. Every kelvin of lower evaporating temperature costs 2%–3% of capacity and COP, so specifying −15 °C “for margin” on a process that needs −8 °C wastes energy for the life of the plant.
How do I handle a cooling water failure?
Fit a fail-safe: on loss of condenser water or power, the reactor control system should stop charging and start the emergency cooling path. A buffer tank at −10 °C buys 15–30 minutes, which is usually enough to bring the batch to a safe hold point.
Does glycol degrade?
Yes, gradually. Ethylene glycol oxidises to glycolic acid, the pH falls and corrosion begins. Test concentration and pH every six months, and change the charge every three to five years. A 35% charge in a 3 m³ loop is a small annual cost against a corroded evaporator.
Related reading