Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Knowledge

Why Chillers Are More Efficient at Part Load, and How to Stage Multiple Machines

The limit is the machine’s minimum stable load: 25%–30% for a screw with slide valve, 20%–30% for a centrifugal with inlet guide vanes, and 10%–15% for a centrifugal with variable inlet guide vanes and diffuser control. Below that, surge or oil-return problems appear and hot-gas bypass is needed — which is efficient only as a last resort.

Staging options

Configuration Minimum plant load Part-load efficiency Redundancy Suited to
1 × 100% 25%–30% Poor below 50% None Small plants, short season
2 × 50% 12%–15% Good 50% on one machine Hotels, offices
3 × 33% 8%–10% Very good 33% Hospitals, campuses
2 × 40% + 1 × 20% 5%–8% Strongest across the range 40% Wide load variation
4 × 25% 6% Good, more maintenance 25% Modular plants, redundancy-driven

The general rule: choose the number of machines so that the smallest step is no larger than the load at which the plant spends significant time. For a hotel with a deep night turndown, that usually means at least three steps.

The staging sequence matters as much as the count

Strategy How it works Effect
Fixed sequence, equal run hours Machines start in order, hours equalised over the year Simple; adequate for most plants
Sequence by efficiency at current load Controller picks the combination with the lowest kW per kW of cooling Lowest energy use; needs part-load data in the controller
Lead machine with VFD One variable-speed machine trims, fixed machines base-load Smooth, but only if the VFD machine is sized for the trim range
All machines at equal part load Load shared equally Good for oil return and hours, worse for efficiency

The most common design error is a fixed sequence where the largest machine always leads. At 30% load the large machine runs at its minimum, cycling or bypassing, while a smaller machine sitting idle would have run at its sweet spot.

A worked comparison

A plant needs 1,000 kW peak, 4,000 full-load-equivalent hours.

Configuration Annual energy at part load Comment
1 × 1,000 kW, IPLV 6.0 667,000 kWh Runs below 50% for half the year
2 × 500 kW, IPLV 6.8 588,000 kWh One machine off at low load
3 × 350 kW, IPLV 7.0 571,000 kWh Deepest turndown, more maintenance
2 × 500 kW with VFD lead, IPLV 7.3 548,000 kWh Highest capital, lowest energy

At USD 0.09/kWh, the difference between the first and last is about USD 10,700 a year — which is roughly the price premium of the VFD machine.

Frequently asked questions

Is a higher full-load COP or a higher IPLV more important?

IPLV, for almost every HVAC plant, because full load is rare. The exception is a process load that runs at 100% continuously, where full-load COP is the right metric.

Can I improve part-load performance without replacing the chiller?

Often yes: fix the staging sequence, add a buffer tank, clean the condenser (which lowers condensing temperature at every load), and fit a VFD to the chilled water pump. These together can recover 8%–15%.

How low can a chiller run before it surges?

A centrifugal typically surges below 20%–25% of design flow unless it has variable inlet guide vanes and diffuser control; a screw is stable to about 25% with a slide valve. Below that, hot-gas bypass keeps it running at poor efficiency.

Does adding machines always improve efficiency?

No. Each machine has parasitic loads and its own minimum. Beyond four or five machines the control complexity and maintenance cost outweigh the part-load gain, unless redundancy is the driver.

Should machines be equal size or different?

Different sizes give finer steps and better efficiency across a wide load range, at the cost of more spares. Equal sizes are simpler and give better redundancy. Hospitals and data centers usually choose equal sizes for redundancy; hotels and commercial buildings often benefit from 2 × 40% + 1 × 20%.

How do I know my plant is staging badly?

Compare the plant kW per kW of cooling at 25%, 50% and 75% load with the design data. If the plant efficiency at 50% is worse than at 75%, the staging sequence or the minimum load is wrong.

Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. supplies part-load performance tables at 25%, 50%, 75% and 100% with every chiller quotation, so the staging arrangement can be modeled before the plant is built. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280

Related reading

Frequently asked questions