Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Knowledge

Chiller Refrigerant Leak: Symptoms, Detection and Repair

The symptoms, in the order they appear

Stage What you notice Why
Early Run hours up 5%–10%, leaving water slow to reach setpoint Less refrigerant mass flow, longer run time
Early Oil staining or dust clinging to one joint Oil migrates with escaping refrigerant
Moderate Superheat above 12 K, suction pressure 0.03–0.08 MPa low Evaporator starved
Moderate Bubbles in the liquid sight glass Flash gas in the liquid line
Advanced Low-pressure trip at part load, frost on the evaporator inlet Pressure below the cut-out
Advanced Compressor overheating, oil discoloured or acidic Poor suction cooling of the motor

A chiller can lose 15%–20% of its charge and still run, which is exactly why the early signs matter: at that point the machine is consuming 10% more electricity for the same output, and nobody has noticed.

Where leaks actually occur

Location Frequency Note
Flare and braze joints Very common Vibration and poor brazing practice
Valve stems and Schrader ports Common Cap missing or seal perished
Tube-to-tubesheet joints Common on shell-and-tube Thermal cycling, poor roller expansion
Pressure relief valve Occasional Relief discharges and does not reseat
Sensor ports and gauge connections Occasional Disturbed during service
Tube wall perforation Rare but serious Water ingress, then acid and sludge
Welded shell seams Rare Manufacturing defect

Water in the circuit is the worst outcome: it forms hydrochloric and hydrofluoric acids, attacks the windings and produces sludge that blocks the expansion valve. If the leak is a tube perforation, the repair is a tube plug or replacement plus a full oil and filter-drier change.

Detection methods

Method Sensitivity Suited to Limitation
Electronic leak detector 5–10 g/year General survey, joints and valve stems False alarms in drafts or with solvent vapors
Soap solution 10–50 g/year Confirming a located leak Slow; misses hidden joints
UV dye with UV lamp 5 g/year Repeated slow leaks, hard-to-reach areas Dye stays in the system; some warranties restrict it
Ultrasonic detector 10–30 g/year Pressurised systems in noisy plant rooms Directional; needs practice
Nitrogen pressure test Any gross leak After a repair, before evacuation Requires isolation and dry nitrogen
Vacuum decay test Small leaks Final check before charging Only detects leaks that admit air

Start with an electronic detector at the known leak points, then confirm with soap. A leak that cannot be found may be inside the evaporator or condenser shell — isolate the circuit and pressure-test each side separately.

The repair procedure

  1. Recover the remaining refrigerant into a recovery cylinder. Do not vent it — this is both a legal requirement in most jurisdictions and a safety issue.
  2. Locate and repair. Braze with dry nitrogen purge to prevent internal oxidation; replace Schrader cores and caps rather than tightening them.
  3. Pressure test with oxygen-free dry nitrogen to the test pressure in the manual, usually 1.0–1.5 times the design pressure, and hold it for at least 24 hours with a temperature-corrected reading.
  4. Triple evacuate to below 200 microns (270 Pa), breaking the vacuum with dry nitrogen between stages.
  5. Charge by weight, not by pressure, with the refrigerant named on the nameplate.
  6. Record the quantity recovered, the quantity charged, the leak location and the repair method — this log is required for compliance in many markets and is the first thing an auditor asks for.

Refrigerant choice matters for compliance

Refrigerant GWP (AR4) Typical use Note
R22 1,810 Legacy machines Phased out under the Montreal Protocol; reclaimed gas only
R410A 2,088 Air-cooled and small water-cooled Being replaced in new designs in some markets
R134a 1,430 Centrifugal and screw Subject to HFC phase-down quotas
R513A 631 Drop-in for R134a in many machines Lower GWP, similar performance
R1234ze under 7 Low-pressure centrifugal Very low GWP, larger machine volume

Under the Kigali Amendment and the EU F-gas Regulation, HFC consumption is being reduced in steps, and larger charges must be leak-checked at defined intervals with records kept. When a machine with R22 or R134a needs a major repair, compare the cost of repair with replacement using a lower-GWP refrigerant.

Preventing the next leak

  • Fit vibration eliminators on the discharge line and support the piping properly; most joint failures are fatigue.
  • Keep valve caps and Schrader caps fitted — a missing cap is a leak path.
  • Do not over-tighten flare nuts; torque to the specification with a torque wrench.
  • Check relief valves during annual service and replace any that have discharged.
  • Log the sight glass and superheat monthly; a trend beats a fault code.
  • Keep the water side clean and treated — a perforated tube is a refrigerant leak and a water leak at once.

Frequently asked questions

How much refrigerant loss is acceptable?

None. Manufacturers allow a tolerance for charging and recovery, not for annual loss. A system that needs gas every year has a leak, even if it is small.

Can I top up without finding the leak?

You can, and many sites do, but it is expensive and increasingly non-compliant. Topping up a 200 kg charge by 10% a year releases 20 kg of high-GWP gas and never addresses the cause.

How do I know the leak is in the evaporator?

Isolate the circuit, pressure-test the shell side separately, and check for water in the oil or a rising moisture indication. A tube perforation usually shows as acid in the oil and a blocked filter drier within weeks.

Is R22 still available?

Only as reclaimed or recycled gas in most markets, and its use in new equipment is prohibited. A chiller running R22 that needs a major repair is usually a candidate for replacement.

What does a proper evacuation look like?

Below 200 microns held for at least 30 minutes with the pump isolated, after a triple evacuation with dry nitrogen breaks. A single-stage evacuation to 500 microns does not remove moisture from the oil.

How often must leak checks be done?

It depends on the charge size and jurisdiction — under the EU F-gas rules, for example, checks start at a 5 tCO₂e charge and become more frequent as the charge rises. Record every check; the log is part of the compliance obligation.

Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. pressure-tests and evacuates every circuit before charging, records the charge weight on the unit and in the handover file, and supplies the leak-check schedule for the refrigerant used. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280

Related reading

Frequently asked questions