The symptoms, in the order they appear
| Stage | What you notice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Early | Run hours up 5%–10%, leaving water slow to reach setpoint | Less refrigerant mass flow, longer run time |
| Early | Oil staining or dust clinging to one joint | Oil migrates with escaping refrigerant |
| Moderate | Superheat above 12 K, suction pressure 0.03–0.08 MPa low | Evaporator starved |
| Moderate | Bubbles in the liquid sight glass | Flash gas in the liquid line |
| Advanced | Low-pressure trip at part load, frost on the evaporator inlet | Pressure below the cut-out |
| Advanced | Compressor overheating, oil discoloured or acidic | Poor suction cooling of the motor |
A chiller can lose 15%–20% of its charge and still run, which is exactly why the early signs matter: at that point the machine is consuming 10% more electricity for the same output, and nobody has noticed.
Where leaks actually occur
| Location | Frequency | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Flare and braze joints | Very common | Vibration and poor brazing practice |
| Valve stems and Schrader ports | Common | Cap missing or seal perished |
| Tube-to-tubesheet joints | Common on shell-and-tube | Thermal cycling, poor roller expansion |
| Pressure relief valve | Occasional | Relief discharges and does not reseat |
| Sensor ports and gauge connections | Occasional | Disturbed during service |
| Tube wall perforation | Rare but serious | Water ingress, then acid and sludge |
| Welded shell seams | Rare | Manufacturing defect |
Water in the circuit is the worst outcome: it forms hydrochloric and hydrofluoric acids, attacks the windings and produces sludge that blocks the expansion valve. If the leak is a tube perforation, the repair is a tube plug or replacement plus a full oil and filter-drier change.
Detection methods
| Method | Sensitivity | Suited to | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electronic leak detector | 5–10 g/year | General survey, joints and valve stems | False alarms in drafts or with solvent vapors |
| Soap solution | 10–50 g/year | Confirming a located leak | Slow; misses hidden joints |
| UV dye with UV lamp | 5 g/year | Repeated slow leaks, hard-to-reach areas | Dye stays in the system; some warranties restrict it |
| Ultrasonic detector | 10–30 g/year | Pressurised systems in noisy plant rooms | Directional; needs practice |
| Nitrogen pressure test | Any gross leak | After a repair, before evacuation | Requires isolation and dry nitrogen |
| Vacuum decay test | Small leaks | Final check before charging | Only detects leaks that admit air |
Start with an electronic detector at the known leak points, then confirm with soap. A leak that cannot be found may be inside the evaporator or condenser shell — isolate the circuit and pressure-test each side separately.
The repair procedure
- Recover the remaining refrigerant into a recovery cylinder. Do not vent it — this is both a legal requirement in most jurisdictions and a safety issue.
- Locate and repair. Braze with dry nitrogen purge to prevent internal oxidation; replace Schrader cores and caps rather than tightening them.
- Pressure test with oxygen-free dry nitrogen to the test pressure in the manual, usually 1.0–1.5 times the design pressure, and hold it for at least 24 hours with a temperature-corrected reading.
- Triple evacuate to below 200 microns (270 Pa), breaking the vacuum with dry nitrogen between stages.
- Charge by weight, not by pressure, with the refrigerant named on the nameplate.
- Record the quantity recovered, the quantity charged, the leak location and the repair method — this log is required for compliance in many markets and is the first thing an auditor asks for.
Refrigerant choice matters for compliance
| Refrigerant | GWP (AR4) | Typical use | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| R22 | 1,810 | Legacy machines | Phased out under the Montreal Protocol; reclaimed gas only |
| R410A | 2,088 | Air-cooled and small water-cooled | Being replaced in new designs in some markets |
| R134a | 1,430 | Centrifugal and screw | Subject to HFC phase-down quotas |
| R513A | 631 | Drop-in for R134a in many machines | Lower GWP, similar performance |
| R1234ze | under 7 | Low-pressure centrifugal | Very low GWP, larger machine volume |
Under the Kigali Amendment and the EU F-gas Regulation, HFC consumption is being reduced in steps, and larger charges must be leak-checked at defined intervals with records kept. When a machine with R22 or R134a needs a major repair, compare the cost of repair with replacement using a lower-GWP refrigerant.
Preventing the next leak
- Fit vibration eliminators on the discharge line and support the piping properly; most joint failures are fatigue.
- Keep valve caps and Schrader caps fitted — a missing cap is a leak path.
- Do not over-tighten flare nuts; torque to the specification with a torque wrench.
- Check relief valves during annual service and replace any that have discharged.
- Log the sight glass and superheat monthly; a trend beats a fault code.
- Keep the water side clean and treated — a perforated tube is a refrigerant leak and a water leak at once.
Frequently asked questions
How much refrigerant loss is acceptable?
None. Manufacturers allow a tolerance for charging and recovery, not for annual loss. A system that needs gas every year has a leak, even if it is small.
Can I top up without finding the leak?
You can, and many sites do, but it is expensive and increasingly non-compliant. Topping up a 200 kg charge by 10% a year releases 20 kg of high-GWP gas and never addresses the cause.
How do I know the leak is in the evaporator?
Isolate the circuit, pressure-test the shell side separately, and check for water in the oil or a rising moisture indication. A tube perforation usually shows as acid in the oil and a blocked filter drier within weeks.
Is R22 still available?
Only as reclaimed or recycled gas in most markets, and its use in new equipment is prohibited. A chiller running R22 that needs a major repair is usually a candidate for replacement.
What does a proper evacuation look like?
Below 200 microns held for at least 30 minutes with the pump isolated, after a triple evacuation with dry nitrogen breaks. A single-stage evacuation to 500 microns does not remove moisture from the oil.
How often must leak checks be done?
It depends on the charge size and jurisdiction — under the EU F-gas rules, for example, checks start at a 5 tCO₂e charge and become more frequent as the charge rises. Record every check; the log is part of the compliance obligation.
Longkang Environmental Equipment Co., Ltd. pressure-tests and evacuates every circuit before charging, records the charge weight on the unit and in the handover file, and supplies the leak-check schedule for the refrigerant used. Phone: +86 400-878-0280 | +86 130-0200-1280
Related reading