Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Heat pump · Hot water · Heating · Cooling

Air-Source Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: A Real Operating-Cost Comparison

“Is a heat pump cheaper than a gas boiler?” cannot be answered from a brochure. The answer depends on three prices and one climate: the electricity tariff, the gas tariff, the boiler efficiency and the heat pump’s seasonal COP. Change any one and the ranking can move.

The useful method is to convert both options to a cost per kWh of delivered heat. That puts electricity, gas, efficiency and part-load behavior on the same basis. This article gives the formula, a worked comparison, the capital and hidden-cost side, and the conditions under which gas remains the better choice.

Prices are illustrative and expressed in USD. Use the site’s actual tariff, including demand charges, taxes and time-of-use bands.

1. The only fair comparison: cost per kWh of heat

For a heat pump:

CostHP = electricity price (USD/kWh) ÷ seasonal COP

For a gas boiler:

Costgas = gas price (USD/kWh, LHV) ÷ boiler efficiency

If gas is priced per m³, convert with the lower heating value: natural gas is about 9.5–10.5 kWh/m³, so a price of USD 0.55/m³ is about USD 0.055/kWh. A condensing boiler at 92% efficiency delivers heat at 0.055 ÷ 0.92 = USD 0.060/kWh.

A heat pump at COP 3.2 and electricity at USD 0.11/kWh delivers heat at 0.11 ÷ 3.2 = USD 0.034/kWh. The heat pump is about 43% cheaper per kWh. At a winter COP of 2.2, the cost rises to USD 0.050/kWh, still 17% below the condensing boiler.

Option Input price Efficiency / COP Cost per kWh heat
Electric resistance USD 0.11/kWh 0.98 USD 0.112
Gas boiler, condensing USD 0.055/kWh 0.92 USD 0.060
Gas boiler, standard USD 0.055/kWh 0.80 USD 0.069
Heat pump, mild weather USD 0.11/kWh 3.6 USD 0.031
Heat pump, design winter USD 0.11/kWh 2.2 USD 0.050
Heat pump, annual average USD 0.11/kWh 3.0 USD 0.037

The annual average COP is the number that matters for operating cost, not the nominal COP at 7 °C. A unit rated at COP 4.0 may average 2.8–3.2 across a heating season, depending on climate and supply temperature.

2. Worked example: 1,000 kW·h of daily heat

Take a hotel needing 1,000 kW·h of delivered heat per day, 330 days a year.

Gas boiler at 92%: fuel input = 1,000 ÷ 0.92 = 1,087 kW·h; at USD 0.055/kWh = USD 59.8/day; annual USD 19,700.

Heat pump at annual COP 3.0: electricity = 1,000 ÷ 3.0 = 333 kW·h; at USD 0.11/kWh = USD 36.7/day; annual USD 12,100.

Annual saving: USD 7,600. If the heat-pump system costs USD 45,000 more than the boiler plant, the simple payback is about 5.9 years. At a COP of 3.5, the saving rises to about USD 9,350 and the payback falls to 4.8 years.

Now change the tariffs. If gas is USD 0.04/kWh and electricity USD 0.16/kWh, gas heat costs USD 0.0435/kWh and heat-pump heat at COP 3.0 costs USD 0.0533/kWh. Gas wins on operating cost, and the heat-pump payback disappears unless there is a grant or a carbon price.

Electricity Gas HP at COP 3.0 Gas at 92% Cheaper
0.10 0.055 0.033 0.060 Heat pump
0.11 0.055 0.037 0.060 Heat pump
0.14 0.055 0.047 0.060 Heat pump
0.16 0.040 0.053 0.043 Gas
0.20 0.040 0.067 0.043 Gas

3. Capital cost and the incremental payback

Compare the incremental capital, not the total price. A gas boiler plant includes the boiler, flue, gas connection, safety controls and annual inspection. A heat-pump plant includes the units, buffer tank, larger electrical supply, controls and defrost drainage. In many projects the heat-pump system is 20–50% more expensive upfront.

Payback = incremental capital ÷ annual operating saving. Use the annual average COP and the actual load profile; a hotel with a 60% summer load will have a different annual COP from a factory running at full load all year.

Include the cost of capital and the equipment life. A heat pump may last 12–15 years; a gas boiler 15–20 years. If the heat pump needs one compressor replacement in year 10, the lifecycle cost changes. Do not compare only first cost and first-year energy.

4. Hidden costs that change the answer

Gas connection. A new gas service, meter, flue and safety inspection can add 10–20% to the boiler plant. In a remote site with no gas main, the connection may exceed the entire heat-pump premium.

Electrical capacity. Heat pumps draw more electrical power than a boiler. A 1,000 kW heat load at COP 3 needs about 333 kW, versus a gas boiler’s small electrical demand. If the building needs a transformer upgrade, include it.

Water quality. Gas boilers are sensitive to scale at high temperature; heat pumps are sensitive to scale at lower temperature but with larger water volumes. Both need water treatment, but the failure modes differ.

Carbon and permits. Gas combustion produces about 0.20 kg CO2/kWh heat at 92% efficiency. Grid electricity at 0.55 kg CO2/kWh and COP 3.0 gives about 0.18 kg/kWh — a small advantage. At a cleaner grid, the heat pump advantage grows; at a coal-heavy grid, it shrinks. If the site has a carbon price or a green-building requirement, include it.

Low-temperature operation. A standard heat pump may need electric backup below −7 °C. Backup resistance has a COP near 1, and the annual average COP falls. A cold-climate unit with vapor injection costs more but avoids the backup penalty.

5. When gas still wins

Very low gas price, high electricity price. The table above shows the crossover. If gas is USD 0.04/kWh and electricity USD 0.18/kWh, gas is cheaper even at COP 3.2.

High-temperature process steam. A boiler delivering 120 °C steam or 90 °C hot water may be the right choice; a standard heat pump cannot reach that temperature efficiently. High-temperature heat pumps exist but cost more and have lower COP.

Very cold climate with a weak grid. At −20 °C, a standard heat pump’s capacity and COP fall sharply. A hybrid system — heat pump for most of the year, boiler for the coldest weeks — is often the most economic compromise.

Limited electrical supply. If the site cannot get more power, a boiler may be the only practical option without a major utility upgrade.

6. Hybrid design: use each where it is best

A bivalent system uses the heat pump as the lead source and the boiler as the peak source. The changeover point is set by the outdoor temperature or by the heat-pump capacity. This reduces the heat-pump size, avoids electric backup, and keeps the boiler for the few coldest days. The control sequence must prevent the boiler from running below its condensing range and prevent the heat pump from short cycling.

For a hotel or factory with an existing boiler, a hybrid retrofit can be staged: install the heat pump first, keep the boiler for peak and standby, and measure the actual saving before expanding. This is lower-risk than a full replacement.

Frequently asked questions

What COP should I use in the comparison?

Use the seasonal COP at the actual climate, not the rated COP at 7°C. A heat pump that delivers COP 3.5 in mild weather may fall to 2.0 at −10°C. Use bin-hour weather data and the unit’s capacity table, including defrost penalty.

How do I compare against a gas boiler?

Convert both to cost per delivered kWh: gas price per kWh divided by boiler efficiency, versus electricity price divided by seasonal COP. Then add maintenance, standing losses and capacity charge. A heat pump can win at low gas prices only if its seasonal COP is high.

What about emissions?

Use the local grid emissions factor and the boiler’s combustion factor. A heat pump shifts emissions to the power sector; with a coal-heavy grid its CO2 advantage may be small. Report both operating cost and CO2, not one alone.

Does cold climate change the answer?

Yes. Capacity derating means a larger unit or backup, and defrost adds energy and downtime. In very cold climates a hybrid—heat pump for most hours, boiler for peaks—often has the lowest cost and best reliability.

How long does the comparison run?

Use at least a full year of hourly load, including summer hot-water demand and winter heating. A single design day hides part-load behavior, which decides most of the annual cost.

What maintenance should be included?

Gas boiler: annual service, flue and safety checks. Heat pump: filter and coil cleaning, refrigerant checks, defrost and controls. Ignoring maintenance makes either option look cheaper than it is.

When is a hybrid best?

When the heat pump covers 60–80% of annual energy and the boiler covers the coldest peak. This reduces electrical capacity, keeps reliability and avoids oversizing the heat pump for a few hours.

What should the final report show?

Annual energy, cost, CO2, capital, maintenance and payback, with sensitivities for fuel price, electricity price and climate. Show the assumptions and the meter boundaries.

Related reading

Heat pump vs gas boiler cost · Inverter heat-pump part-load efficiency · Coal-to-electric heat-pump retrofit