A heat-pump tender often runs to hundreds of pages, but the technical evaluation starts at one table: the parameter response. The evaluator reads the requirement, the bid value and the evidence in sequence. A value without a condition, or a condition without a test report, is a clarification at best and a rejection at worst.
The common failure is not a bad product. It is a good product described badly: “40 kW” without saying whether it is at 20 °C or 7 °C, “COP 4.2” without the standard, or “system produces 30 t/day” supported only by a unit capacity. The response table must connect the unit, the system and the site condition.
1. The nominal condition is not the design condition
GB/T 21362-2008 defines the nominal condition for a heat-pump water heater as 20 °C dry bulb / 15 °C wet bulb, 15 °C inlet water and 55 °C outlet water. Catalog capacity and COP normally refer to that condition. The project design condition is rarely the same: a northern winter may be −5 °C ambient with 5 °C inlet water, where capacity falls to 55–70% of nominal.
The response table should therefore have two rows for capacity and two for COP: nominal and design. A single nominal row tells the evaluator that the bidder has not read the design condition.
| Item | Tender requirement | Bid response | Deviation | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nominal capacity | ≥ 40 kW | 42.5 kW at 20/15 °C, 15→55 °C | +6.3% | Test report, catalog page 8 |
| Design capacity | ≥ 28 kW at −5 °C | 29.6 kW at −5 °C, 5→55 °C | +5.7% | Low-temperature test report |
| Nominal COP | ≥ 4.2 | 4.35 | +3.6% | Efficiency test report |
| Design COP | ≥ 2.0 at −5 °C | 2.14 | +7.0% | Same report |
| Outlet range | 45–55 °C | 40–60 °C | Positive | Controller manual |
| Compressor | Scroll | Scroll, Copeland ZW | None | Nameplate photo |
| Refrigerant | R410A | R32 | Negative | Safety and charge comparison |
2. Unit capacity is not system capacity
A tender that requires “30 metric tons of hot water per day” is asking for a system output, not a compressor rating. Convert the requirement into heat: 30 m³ from 10 °C to 55 °C is 30 × 1.163 × 45 = 1,570 kWh/day. If one unit delivers 21 m³/day at the design condition, two units are needed, and the response should show the calculation, the unit count and the storage volume.
The same logic applies to recovery. A 40 kW unit heating a 5 m³ tank from 15 °C to 55 °C takes 46.5 × 5 / 40 ≈ 5.8 hours, before losses. If the tender requires recovery in four hours, one unit is not enough, whatever the catalog says.
3. COP and efficiency grade are different claims
“Grade 1” is an energy-label classification. “COP 4.35” is a measured value at a defined condition. They cannot substitute for each other. A complete response states the grade, the standard (GB/T 21362-2008 or GB 29541-2013), the test report number and the condition. A response that says only “Grade 1” leaves the evaluator unable to verify the value.
4. Negative deviations
Some deviations are technical choices, not defects. A different refrigerant, a slightly larger footprint or a higher noise level can be acceptable if the bidder explains the effect and the mitigation. The response should quantify the deviation: for R32 versus R410A, state the charge reduction, the efficiency comparison, the safety class (A2L) and the installation measures. Do not hide a negative deviation inside a “compiles with” line.
Material deviations are different. A 201 stainless tank instead of 304 is a durability choice, not an equivalent. If the tender requires 304, a 201 response is likely to be treated as non-responsive, and it should be.
5. The supply boundary
Most post-award disputes are about scope, not performance. Write the eight boundaries into the bid: unit and starter panel; tank and insulation; circulation pump and standby; piping, valves and strainer; electrical supply and isolation; foundation and vibration isolation; freeze protection; commissioning and training. The two most commonly omitted are the circulation pump and the electrical supply. If the owner supplies the pump, the bid must state the required flow and head; otherwise a later pump selection becomes the supplier’s fault in the owner’s mind.
6. Commercial evidence
References should match the offered model and application, with contract pages and acceptance certificates. A reference for a different model is not a reference.
Service should name the local office, the resident technicians, the spare-parts location and the response time. “24-hour response” without an address is not a commitment.
Warranty should separate the whole unit, the compressor and the wear parts, and state whether water-quality damage is covered. A two-year whole-unit warranty that excludes the heat exchanger is narrower than it sounds.
Common questions
What happens if the response omits the condition?
The evaluator may request a clarification; if the clarification does not resolve it, the item can be treated as non-responsive. In execution, the omitted condition becomes the supplier’s risk.
Which standard should the COP cite?
GB/T 21362-2008 for the heat-pump water heater, or the standard named in the tender. State the year and the test report number.
How is low-temperature capacity proven?
With a test report at the design ambient and inlet temperature, or a manufacturer’s correction curve with a stated basis. A catalog “low-temperature model” claim is not a test.
Can a negative deviation be accepted?
Yes, if it is disclosed, quantified and mitigated, and the tender allows it. A hidden negative deviation is the problem.
Should the bid include the tank and pump?
Include them if the tender defines a system. If the owner supplies them, state the interface requirements and the design flow and head.
What is the most common technical rejection?
A capacity or COP value without a condition or a traceable report. The second most common is a response that covers the unit but not the system.
What capacity claim?
State the duty, ambient and fouling allowance. A bare tonnage claim fails review. The reviewer needs the conditions behind the number.
What evidence?
A test report, a reference plant and a calculation. Each should match the claimed duty. A catalog page is not evidence.
Further technical reading
- Heat-Pump Acceptance Standards
- Heat-Pump Model Codes
- Heat-Pump Price Factors
- Heat-Pump Commissioning Checklist
LONGCOM can prepare the two-condition response table, the system capacity calculation and the scope boundary for a heat-pump tender, and align the test reports with the offered model. For a tender review, contact 400-878-0280 or 13002001280.
Related reading
Heat Pump Factory Audit Low Temperature · Heat Pump Project Questions · Heat Pump Price Factors