Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Heat pump · Hot water · Heating · Cooling

Heat-Pump Factory Audit: Test at -7 °C, Not on Paper

Three quotations for the same 30 kW heat-pump plant can differ by 40%. The difference is rarely profit. One supplier makes the chassis, coils and controls; one buys the parts and assembles; one forward a price from another factory. All three can provide a glossy catalog. Only one can tell you which heat exchanger will be available in year eight.

The audit is not a search for the biggest name. It is a check of identity, model-specific evidence and low-temperature performance. This article sets out the four factory checkpoints, the six documents, the -7 °C witness test and the five contract clauses that make the audit useful.

First, establish the identity

Ask for the production address and a list of in-house processes. A manufacturer with a fin press, tube expander, bending line, sheet-metal paint line and an integrated performance test bench is a real manufacturer. A supplier with only an assembly line is an assembler. A supplier that cannot name a production address is a trader.

None of these identities is automatically bad. A trader is convenient for a small or urgent order. For a project above CNY 1 million, however, the service and spare-parts chain matters more than the first price. The audit should establish which identity you are dealing with before you compare the numbers.

Four factory checkpoints

Checkpoint What good looks like What to question
Performance test bench Integrated enthalpy lab; range covers the offered model; each unit logged Component-only test or third-party report for a different size
Coil production Fin press, tube expander and bender in-house All coils bought in; only assembly on site
Work in progress The offered model is in production or in stock Only small units visible; the large unit is “made after order”
Loaded run area At least 4 hours of loaded run before dispatch, with a record Power-on test only, no water loop or load

Two hours on the floor are enough to see these four points. Look at the test-bench nameplate range, not the brochure. A bench that stops at 20 kW cannot witness a 40 kW unit at full load. Ask for the last three dispatch records of the same model and see whether the capacity, power and water temperatures were recorded or only a pass/fail box was ticked.

Six documents, checked by number

Business license and scope. Check the national enterprise credit system. A scope that does not include refrigeration equipment manufacturing is a warning, not a disqualification; the supplier may be a trader.

ISO 9001. Check the certificate number and expiry on the certification body’s site. A certificate that covers “sales” but not “design and manufacture” does not cover the factory.

CCC certificate. CCC is issued by model. A certificate for a 5 kW unit does not cover a 40 kW unit. Read the annex and find the offered model in the list.

Efficiency report. The sample model must match the offered model. A report for a smaller unit in the same “series” is not a report for the unit you are buying.

Low-temperature report. Ask for measured data at -7 °C or -12 °C: heating capacity, input power and COP. A nominal-condition report plus a “correction curve” is not a witness test.

Patents and software copyrights. Useful context, not proof of manufacturing capability. An appearance patent does not tell you whether the coil can be replaced.

The -7 °C witness test

The most useful test is not at 7 °C. It is at the ambient condition where the project actually needs heat. For a cold-climate project, witness at -7 °C with the design leaving-water temperature, and again at -12 °C if the site requires it.

Test point Record Why it matters
Nominal capacity Heating capacity, input power, COP at 7 °C Baseline for the catalog number
Low-temperature capacity Capacity, power, COP at -7 °C Defines the real unit size for winter
Defrost Defrost interval, duration, capacity recovery A unit can pass a steady test and fail in cycling
Leaving water Temperature at design flow, not reduced flow Low flow flatters the capacity number

A 30 kW nominal unit may deliver 18–22 kW at -7 °C, depending on compressor, coil and refrigerant. That is not a fault; it is physics. The fault is buying 30 kW of nominal capacity for a 25 kW winter load without asking for the -7 °C number. The witness test should use the design water flow and the design leaving-water temperature, and it should record the defrost cycle.

References: three items, not a photo album

Ask for the contract page showing the equipment list and model, the acceptance certificate with the owner’s stamp, and a site photo showing the unit nameplate. A photo of a hotel mechanical room proves a hotel exists; it does not prove the same model was installed or that it works.

Ask three questions: Is the project still running? What outlet temperature does it actually hold? What failed in the first two years? A supplier who answers with numbers and names has a service record. A supplier who answers “all projects are good” has a brochure. Reference similarity matters more than reference count: a school dormitory and a five-star hotel have different draw profiles, installation constraints and maintenance teams.

Five contract clauses

Clause Write this If omitted
Model and configuration Compressor brand and model; coil type, rows and fin spacing; controller model A substitute arrives and the price looks the same
Performance Test condition, flow, leaving-water temperature and remedy if short Dispute after the first winter
Spare parts At least 8 years after discontinuation; key parts price list No coil available in year six
Service On-site response time, nearest parts stock, named technician “24-hour response” becomes a call center
Warranty Unit, compressor and controller listed separately; water quality exclusions stated Year-two failure blamed on the site

The first clause is the one most often softened. “High-efficiency scroll compressor” is not a specification. Write the brand and model. “High-efficiency heat exchanger” is not a specification. Write brazed plate or shell-and-tube, the surface area and the material. These details do not change the sales story; they decide the repair bill in year five.

Boundary

A full factory audit is not economic for a CNY 300,000 project. For small projects, concentrate on the model-specific reports and the contract clauses. For imported brands assembled locally, check the local spare-parts stock rather than the foreign factory. When buying through an engineering contractor, audit the manufacturer but sign with the contractor; confirm the manufacturer’s authorization and the responsibility boundary in writing.

Common questions

How do I tell a manufacturer from an assembler?

Ask for the production address and the in-house process list. Fin press, tube expander, bender, paint line and an integrated test bench indicate manufacturing. An assembly line only indicates assembly; no address indicates a trader.

Which certificate is most often mismatched?

CCC and the efficiency report. CCC is issued by model, so a certificate for a small unit does not cover a large one. The efficiency report sample model must match the offered model, including any suffix.

Why test at -7 °C?

Because the nominal 7 °C capacity is not the winter capacity. A 30 kW nominal unit may deliver 18–22 kW at -7 °C. The project should be sized on the low-temperature number, not the catalog headline.

Is a 4-hour loaded run enough?

It is a practical minimum for a factory witness test. It catches assembly faults, control faults and refrigerant leaks. It does not prove five-year reliability; that requires reference sites and spare-parts evidence.

What should the contract say about spare parts?

At least eight years of supply after discontinuation, with a price list for the coil, compressor, controller and fans. Without it, a working unit can become scrap for want of one part.

Does a lower price always mean a trader?

No. It can mean a smaller coil, a different compressor, a thinner frame or a shorter warranty. Compare the configuration line by line before comparing the total.

What test point?

-7 °C ambient with the design water flow. A paper curve at 7 °C does not prove cold-climate capacity.

What data?

Capacity, power, defrost time and supply temperature. Record them at the same time. A single number is not a test.

Further technical reading

For the heat-pump audit, see Heat-Pump Factory Audit. For payback, see Heat Pump Payback. For installation, see Heat-Pump Installation: Six Stages, Three Inspections. For service, see Air-Source Heat Pump Maintenance.

Related reading

Heat Pump Factory Audit Low Temperature · Heat Pump COP Rating · Heat Pump Tender Technical Response