Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Heat pump · Hot water · Heating · Cooling

Heat-Pump Factory Audit: Test the Unit, Not the Brochure

A factory audit is not a tour of the showroom. The question is whether the factory can reproduce the capacity it sells, at the winter point, using the components and records it claims. A brochure can be printed anywhere; a test log, a pressure-hold record and a serial-number trail cannot.

The audit below is written for a commercial hot-water heat pump, typically 10–60 kW per module. It applies equally to a single unit and to a batch before dispatch. The principle is to ask for evidence that can be checked, not for a certificate that can be framed.

Audit the unit, not the catalog

Start with the model code on the order, the nameplate and the controller. A product family may share a casing while differing in compressor, heat exchanger, refrigerant and control board. Ask for the bill of materials for the ordered code and compare it with the unit on the test stand. Record the serial number of the compressor, the expansion valve, the controller and the fan motors. If the factory cannot trace these to the unit, the audit has already found a gap.

Check the refrigerant. R410A, R32 and R290 require different charge limits, leak detection and ventilation rules. The nameplate charge must match the test record, and the service ports must be accessible without removing panels.

Capacity at the winter point

A single nominal capacity at 7 °C ambient and 15 – 55 °C water says little about a winter project. Ask for a capacity table at several ambient temperatures, for example −7, 2, 7, 20 and 35 °C, with water flow and leaving temperature stated. The winter point is the one that sizes the unit. A unit that meets the load at 7 °C but loses 30% at −7 °C will fail in service.

Ask how defrost is included. A capacity table measured with a dry coil is not the same as one measured with frost accumulation and reverse-cycle defrost. The test record should state the defrost interval, the recovery time and whether the published capacity is an average over a complete frost cycle.

The efficiency map, not one COP

One COP at nominal conditions is a label, not a selection tool. Ask for COP at 100%, 75%, 50% and 25% load, and at two or three ambient temperatures. For a hot-water plant, the annual energy depends on part-load behavior, not on the best point. A unit with a high nominal COP but a steep drop at 50% load may lose to a lower-rated unit with a flat curve.

Separate unit COP from system COP. Unit COP covers compressor and fan; system COP adds circulation pumps, defrost energy and standby. If the factory quotes only unit COP, ask for the boundary. A number without a boundary is not comparable with another supplier’s number.

Pressure integrity and refrigerant charge

The pressure test is the part of the audit that cannot be rushed. Ask for the nitrogen hold pressure, the hold time, the allowable drop and the record for the serial number being inspected. A vacuum record should show the final vacuum and the holding time before charging. The charge weight should be printed on the nameplate and recorded on the test sheet.

Look for oil stains at brazed joints, flare connections and the reversing valve. A clean unit can still have a slow leak that only appears after transport. The dispatch inspection should include a second pressure check after the unit is packed, not only at the end of assembly.

Component traceability

The compressor is the first item, but not the only one. Record the compressor model and serial, the expansion valve type, the controller model, the fan motor and the water-side heat exchanger. For the heat exchanger, ask for the design pressure, the material grade and the weld map. For coastal or industrial sites, ask for the fin coating and the coil material, not a generic “anti-corrosion” claim.

Copper thickness and fin pitch matter more than a badge. A coil with a thin wall and a wide fin pitch may pass a short test and fail in a dusty or coastal site. If the factory cannot state the fin pitch and coating thickness, treat the claim as unproven.

Control panel and spare parts

Open the panel. Check the wiring schedule, terminal numbering, circuit-breaker ratings and the separation of power and signal cables. Confirm the controller is the model offered, not a substitute. Ask for the alarm list and the input/output list, and check that the sensors are the type and accuracy stated in the quotation. A unit with a good compressor and a poor panel will still cause callbacks.

Ask for the recommended spare parts list and the lead time for each item. A factory that cannot supply a controller, a pressure sensor or a fan motor within a reasonable period is a risk, however good the test data. The list should distinguish wear parts from insurance parts.

Warranty and test records

Read the warranty exclusions before the audit, not after. The common exclusions are water quality, incorrect installation, unauthorized repair and operation outside the stated envelope. Ask how response time is measured and who attends site. A three-year warranty with a two-week response in a hotel is not equivalent to a one-year warranty with a 48-hour response.

At the end of the audit, request the test report, the pressure record, the charge record, the wiring diagram, the controller parameter list and the packing list. These are the documents that let a third party verify the unit later. If any is missing, record it as an open item rather than accepting a verbal promise.

Audit item Evidence to request Pass criterion
Model identity Order code, nameplate, bill of materials All three match; serial numbers recorded
Winter capacity Capacity table at −7, 2, 7, 20, 35 °C Winter point covers the load with defrost included
Efficiency COP at 25, 50, 75, 100% load Curve is flat enough for the annual load profile
Pressure integrity Nitrogen hold and vacuum record for the serial number No unexplained drop; charge matches nameplate
Components Compressor, valve, controller, coil specification Traceable; no substitution without written approval
Panel Wiring diagram, I/O list, alarm list Terminals and ratings match the quotation
After-sales Warranty terms, response time, spare-parts lead time Exclusions are specific and response is defined

Common questions

How many units should be inspected?

For a batch, inspect at least one unit fully and check the serial records for the rest. For a single critical unit, witness the pressure test and the capacity test, not only the final visual inspection.

Is a type-test certificate enough?

No. A type test proves a design, not the unit in front of you. Ask for the serial-number test record and confirm the production unit uses the same compressor, coil and controller as the type-tested sample.

What is the most common hidden substitution?

The controller and the expansion valve. Both can be changed without affecting the casing, and both affect reliability and part-load performance. Check the model on the unit against the quotation.

Should the audit include a site visit?

Yes, if the project is large or the unit is custom. A site visit shows installation quality, but it cannot replace the factory test records. Use the site visit for references and service capability, and the factory audit for product evidence.

How do I compare two factories fairly?

Give both the same test points, the same water temperatures and the same boundary. Ask for raw data, not only curves. Compare the winter capacity, the part-load COP and the pressure records on the same basis.

What if the factory refuses a witnessed test?

Treat it as a commercial risk, not a technical detail. A factory that cannot witness a standard capacity and pressure test is unlikely to support a warranty claim later. Consider a third-party inspection or a different supplier.

What should the audit test?

Winter capacity, COP, pressure integrity, electrical safety and control sequence. Test the unit at the specified ambient, not just a summer condition.

Which records prove traceability?

Serial-number test sheets, component certificates, calibration and the witness signature. A brochure or a generic certificate is not traceability.

Further technical reading

For the acceptance tests that follow delivery, see Heat Pump Acceptance: Standards and Tests. For model-code reading, see Heat-Pump Product Series: Read the Model Code. For the spare-parts list, see Heat-Pump Spare Parts. For tender evidence, see Heat-Pump Tender: Make the Capacity Claim Survive Review.

Related reading

Heat-pump commissioning · Heat-pump COP rating · Heat-pump acceptance