Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Heat pump · Hot water · Heating · Cooling

Heat-Pump Hot Water and BAS: Points, Priority and Control Logic

Chilled-water BAS logic is “make cooling when the terminals need it”. Hot-water logic is different: the plant stores heat in a tank and uses it later. The BAS therefore controls when to heat and how much to store, not just whether the compressor runs. If the priority order is wrong, the building can run at full output during peak electricity and still run out of hot water at night.

This article sets out a typical point list for a four-unit, 30 m³ plant, the four control loops and their priority, the deadband that prevents short cycling, and the Modbus details that most often go wrong at commissioning.

Point counts and setpoints are illustrative; the actual schedule must follow the unit’s protocol document and the BAS vendor’s requirements.

1. Why hot-water BAS is storage-led

A chiller follows the instantaneous cooling load. A hot-water plant can shift its load: heat during the off-peak window, store at 60 °C, and draw down during the morning or evening peak. The tank is the buffer, and the BAS is the dispatcher.

The control problem is therefore a time–temperature problem: at what time may the plant heat, and to what temperature? The unit’s own controller should handle compressor safety; the BAS handles scheduling, setpoint and monitoring.

2. A typical point list

For four heat-pump units and a 30 m³ tank, a monitoring-only system may need 40–50 points; a control system may need 60–80. The exact count depends on whether pumps, valves and energy meters are included.

Group Points Type Purpose
Each unit Run status, fault, remote/local, supply and return temperature, ambient temperature, compressor current DI / AI Status and performance
Tank Top, middle and bottom temperature AI Stratification and usable volume
Water side Supply flow, return flow, pressure, pump status, pump fault AI / DI Flow and distribution
Setpoints Target temperature, on/off, mode, time schedule AO / DO Dispatch
Energy Heat meter, electricity meter AI KPI and billing
Safety Low temperature, leak, over-temperature, emergency stop DI Protection

Three tank temperature sensors are worth the cost. A single sensor cannot tell you whether the tank is stratified or short-circuiting; top/middle/bottom readings show whether hot water is stored at the top and cold water returned at the bottom.

3. Four control loops, one priority order

Freeze protection — highest priority. If the outdoor temperature falls below 2 °C, start the circulation pump, enable heat trace and, if necessary, the backup heater. A power failure at −10 °C can split a heat exchanger within hours. No energy-saving schedule may override this.

Legionella — second priority. Store at 60 °C or above. If the tank is held at 55 °C, run a weekly pasteurization cycle to 60 °C at the tank outlet for a defined period, then return to normal. The BAS must record the cycle and alarm if it is missed. Delivery temperature is limited by thermostatic mixing valves, not by lowering the tank temperature.

Off-peak storage — third priority. Heat during the low-tariff window to the upper setpoint, then stop. A 30 m³ tank heated from 45 °C to 60 °C stores 30,000 × 4.187 × 15 ÷ 3,600 = 523 kW·h of heat. At a COP of 3.0–3.5, that is 149–174 kW·h of electricity. With a 0.3 CNY/kWh tariff difference, the saving is 45–52 CNY/day, or 16,000–19,000 CNY/year — not 523 × 0.3, which would assume direct electric heating.

Demand and comfort — fourth priority. During the morning and evening peaks, hold 55 °C or above and avoid unnecessary heating. If the tank is still above 50 °C after the peak, pause the plant until the next off-peak window.

The order matters because the loops conflict. A legionella cycle during the evening peak raises demand; a freeze event at night must override the off-peak schedule. Write the priority into the sequence, not into an operator’s memory.

4. Deadband and tank size

A fixed 60 °C setpoint with a 55–60 °C control band causes the unit to cycle continuously. Use a deadband: start at 45 °C, stop at 60 °C, and do nothing in between. A large tank can accept a 10–15 K deadband; a small tank may need 5 K to avoid running out during the peak.

When a retrofit replaces a large tank with a smaller one, the deadband must be reduced and the schedule re-tuned. Otherwise the unit starts and stops far more often than before, and the compressor life suffers.

The BAS should also calculate the usable stored energy from the tank temperatures, not from the nominal volume. A 30 m³ tank at 60 °C with a 45 °C useful limit stores about 523 kW·h; if only the top 10 m³ is hot, the usable energy is much lower.

5. Modbus and BACnet: the details that fail

Register offset. A manufacturer may document “40001” while the actual message address is 0-based. Read one known value — supply temperature — and compare it with the panel before mapping the rest. An offset of one register can shift every value.

Byte order. 32-bit values such as cumulative heat are often stored as two 16-bit registers. If the reading is an absurd number, swap the high and low words. Test with a small value first.

Timeout and fallback. Set a communication timeout of about 60 seconds, alarm on loss, but let the unit continue on its local control. A BAS communication failure must not stop the heat pump.

RS-485 termination. Fit 120 Ω resistors at both ends of the bus, and ground the shield at one end only. Missing termination causes intermittent failures that look like sensor faults.

BACnet gateway. If the BAS uses BACnet, the gateway must support writes and pass exception codes. A read-only gateway cannot change the setpoint, so the off-peak strategy will not work.

6. Commissioning tests

Test the sequence, not just the points. Simulate a tank sensor failure and confirm the plant falls back to a safe setpoint. Disconnect the communication cable and confirm the unit keeps running. Force a low-temperature alarm and confirm the pump and heater start. Run a legionella cycle and confirm the delivery temperature stays below 45 °C at the outlets. Record every test and the resulting trend.

Frequently asked questions

Which BAS points are essential?

Hot-water supply and return temperatures, tank top/mid/bottom temperature, outdoor temperature, heat-pump status and fault, pump status, flow switch, energy meter and alarm. Add defrost status and compressor modulation if available. Do not rely on a single tank sensor.

How should priority be ranked?

First domestic hot water and Legionella safety, then freeze protection, then comfort heating, then off-peak charging. Within hot water, the tank top temperature controls the heat pump; the bottom sensor decides when to recharge. Write the ranking into the sequence, not just the points list.

How is freeze protection sequenced?

Start the pump on low outdoor or return temperature, keep a minimum flow, and enable electric trace or a bypass if the unit cannot run. Do not use the heat pump as a freeze protector below its operating limit. Alarm before pipes freeze.

How is Legionella controlled by the BAS?

Schedule a weekly pasteurization cycle to raise the tank above 60 °C, or store above 60 °C continuously. Log the cycle, the temperature and the duration. Avoid a control sequence that lets the bottom of the tank stay in the 25–45 °C growth range.

How should off-peak charging work?

Use the tariff signal to charge the tank during cheap hours, but cap the tank temperature and respect the heat pump’s minimum run time. Do not start charging at full load at the same moment as a morning draw; stage it.

What demand control is useful?

Limit the number of compressors or the total power during a peak, and shed off-peak charging first. Keep domestic hot water and freeze protection ahead of comfort. Log the shed events so the client can see what was curtailed.

What Modbus problems are common?

Wrong register map, byte order, baud rate, parity, slave address, grounding and termination. Read one known value first, then scale. Keep the poll rate modest and separate the BAS trunk from noisy VFD cables.

What alarms should be surfaced?

Heat-pump fault, low pressure, high pressure, flow loss, tank over-temperature, sensor fault, communication loss and Legionella cycle failure. Group them by consequence, not by device, so the operator knows what to do first.

Related reading

Buffer tank sizing · Factory dormitory hot water · Coal-to-electric heat-pump retrofit