Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Industrial cooling · Process

Magnetic-Bearing Centrifugal Chillers: Principle, Part-Load Efficiency and Project Fit

Magnetic-bearing centrifugal chillers have been in commercial projects for more than a decade, yet they still carry a 20–35% price premium over conventional variable-speed centrifugal machines. The premium is justified by two measurable factors: part-load efficiency and maintenance cost. Whether those factors materialize depends on the load profile and the site services.

1. Five degrees of freedom, five control loops

A conventional centrifugal compressor rotor sits on mechanical bearings lubricated by an oil film. A magnetic-bearing machine replaces the bearings with electromagnets.

The rotor has five degrees of freedom: four radial (horizontal and vertical at each end) and one axial. Five displacement sensors sample rotor position thousands of times per second; the controller adjusts coil current to pull the rotor back to the center. The levitation gap is typically 0.3–0.5 mm.

This is a closed-loop control problem, not a simple “magnet holds the shaft” arrangement. Aerodynamic excitation, load changes and grid disturbances constantly move the rotor; the controller must correct within milliseconds. The control algorithm is the real technical barrier and a major source of difference between suppliers.

Component Quantity Function Consequence of failure
Radial magnetic bearings 2 sets (4 axes) Constrain radial position Rotor rubs; immediate stop
Axial magnetic bearing 1 set Balances impeller thrust Thrust disc wear
Displacement sensors 5 Measure rotor position Control loop opens; rotor drops
Backup mechanical bearings 2 Catch the rotor on power loss One-off use; inspection required
Variable-speed drive 1 set Drives motor and controls speed Unit stops

The backup bearings are a critical design detail. On a sudden power loss the magnetic field disappears and the rotor drops at several thousand rpm. Ceramic or special-alloy backup bearings can survive a limited number of dry-friction landings, but the clearance must be checked after each event. Ask during tender how many landings are permitted before replacement and what replacement costs.

2. Oil-free operation changes three things

Heat-transfer efficiency. Conventional oil-lubricated machines carry a small amount of oil into the condenser, where it forms a film on tube walls. At 0.05 mm, the condenser heat-transfer coefficient can fall by about 5%; the evaporator is usually worse. An oil-free machine has no film, so the heat exchanger can be more compact.

Evaporator type. Without oil, a falling-film evaporator becomes practical. Refrigerant is sprayed over the tube bundle and evaporates as a thin film; the heat-transfer coefficient is 10–15% higher than a flooded evaporator, and refrigerant charge is only 40–60% of a flooded machine. Lower charge matters for HFCs with high global-warming potential.

Maintenance scope. Oil changes, oil filters, oil analysis and oil heaters disappear. For an 800 RT machine, conventional oil-system maintenance may cost USD 4,000–7,000 a year; over ten years that is a substantial part of the magnetic-bearing business case.

Item Conventional VSD centrifugal Magnetic-bearing centrifugal
Bearings Mechanical, forced lubrication Active magnetic, oil-free
Evaporator Mainly flooded Mainly falling-film
Refrigerant charge 100% reference 40–60%
Annual maintenance, 800 RT USD 4,000–7,000 USD 1,500–2,000
Starting current 2–3 × rated ≤ 1.5 × rated
Sound pressure at 1 m 80–85 dB(A) 75–80 dB(A)
Equipment price 100% reference 120–135%

3. Why part-load efficiency can reach 9

The efficiency advantage is concentrated between 30% and 60% load, which is where most commercial buildings operate for most of the year.

Load ratio Fixed-speed centrifugal VSD centrifugal Magnetic-bearing VSD
100% 6.2 6.3 6.4
75% 5.6 6.5 7.1
50% 4.5 6.2 8.6
30% 3.2 5.4 9.1
20% Surge; cannot run 4.6 7.8

Three effects combine:

  • Speed can go much lower. Magnetic-bearing speed is nearly linear with load; at 20% load the shaft may run at about 55% of rated speed. Mechanical bearings cannot build an oil film at such low speed, so a conventional VSD centrifugal typically stops around 60–70%.
  • No gearbox. Conventional centrifugal machines use a gear to increase speed; the gear itself consumes 2–3% and is noisy at high speed. A high-speed direct-drive motor eliminates that loss.
  • Better heat exchangers. No oil film and falling-film evaporation reduce the condensing-to-evaporating temperature difference, lowering the compression ratio and the power per unit of cooling.

At full load, the gap between a magnetic-bearing machine and a good VSD centrifugal is only 2–3%. A project that runs near full load all year, such as some process cooling duties, will struggle to recover the 25% price premium.

4. The electrical side is often underestimated

A magnetic-bearing chiller requires a variable-speed drive, often a high-voltage drive or a dedicated low-voltage high-power drive. Three issues are frequently missing from tender documents.

Harmonics. A six-pulse drive can produce current total harmonic distortion above 30%. On a weak supply, this affects UPS systems and precision equipment on the same bus. Data centers often require distortion below 5%, which means a multi-pulse rectifier or active filter.

Power factor. Drives with built-in correction can reach 0.95 or better; without correction, full-load power factor may be about 0.9 and lower at part load. The utility may require compensation.

Electromagnetic interference. The high-speed motor and drive are strong noise sources. Control cables must be routed separately from power cables, with shielded single-end grounding. Poor practice shows up as sensor signal jumps and unexplained trips.

5. Where magnetic bearings fit

Project type Fit Reason
Offices, mixed-use commercial High Long operating hours at 30–60% load
Data centers High Stable load; high efficiency and low maintenance
Hospitals, hotels Good Large day/night variation; long part-load hours
Process cooling at full load Low Full-load advantage only 2–3%
Frequent start/stop Low Each start consumes backup-bearing life
Weak or distorted grid Evaluate Harmonics and voltage fluctuation affect levitation control

One more constraint is mechanical room temperature. Magnetic-bearing controllers are temperature-sensitive; above 40 °C they may derate or trip. An old, poorly ventilated mechanical room must solve that before specifying the machine.

6. Boundaries behind the claims

The efficiency figures above are typical values at nominal conditions: 7/12 °C chilled water and 32/37 °C cooling water. Higher chilled-water temperature or lower cooling-water temperature will improve all values.

Maintenance costs are estimates for a normal service environment. Remote sites with long response times will pay more. Controllers and sensors are proprietary; they last longer than mechanical parts but cost more per replacement.

Payback depends strongly on the load profile. The same building can show a two-year or four-year payback depending on whether hourly or monthly load data is used. Always calculate with hourly load, not monthly averages.

7. Tender data that separates a real magnetic-bearing offer

The compressor is only one part of the offer. Two machines with the same nominal COP can differ in backup-bearing life, drive harmonics and controller robustness — the three items most often missing from a tender pack.

Item Require in the offer Why it matters
Backup-bearing landings Permitted number of dry-friction landings, inspection procedure and replacement cost A power failure is the design case for the backup bearings; an unlimited claim is not a specification.
Controller ambient range Maximum mechanical room temperature and derating curve above it Magnetic-bearing controllers are temperature-sensitive; an old mechanical room can exceed the limit.
Drive harmonics Current THD at the drive input, with the mitigation offered Data centers and precision processes often limit distortion to 5% or less.
Ride-through and UPS Whether the controller is on UPS, and the safe shutdown sequence on power loss A controlled stop is cheaper than a rotor landing, even when the bearings survive it.
Sensor redundancy Number of displacement sensors, failure detection and fallback logic One sensor failure should not drop the rotor; the control strategy must be described.
Factory and site tests Performance test points, vibration limits and commissioning hold points The part-load advantage is only real if it is measured at 30%, 50% and 75% load.

Ask for the part-load table at the contract’s chilled-water and condenser-water temperatures, not at a nominal rating. A magnetic-bearing machine that is only 2% better at full load may still be the right choice — but the case must be made on annual hours, not on the label.

8. Common questions

Do the bearings wear?

Not in normal operation; there is no contact. Wear occurs only during a power-loss landing on the backup bearings, and clearance must be checked afterward. Design life is typically 20 years or more, provided the supply is stable and landings are rare.

Will a power failure damage the machine?

The rotor lands on the backup bearings and stops by dry friction. The design permits a limited number of landings, but each must be inspected. Critical projects should use a UPS for the controller so the machine can shut down safely instead of dropping.

Is a dedicated drive mandatory?

Yes. Magnetic bearings require variable speed, and the drive and controller are usually matched by the same supplier. Mixing brands can lose the coordination of the levitation loop.

Why is refrigerant charge lower?

Mainly because of the falling-film evaporator: the tube bundle does not need to be flooded with liquid refrigerant. Charge is 40–60% of a flooded machine, which also reduces the cost and impact of a leak.

Is it really quieter?

Typically 5–8 dB(A) lower, mainly because there is no gearbox and the machine can run at lower speed. Fan and pump noise often dominate the mechanical room, so treat the whole system, not only the chiller.

Can it be used for ice storage?

Yes, but ice-building evaporating temperature can be around −6 °C, which raises the pressure ratio. A dual-duty machine is required, and both night ice-building and day cooling points must be checked.

What is a magnetic bearing?

A shaft levitated by magnetic force, with no oil. It reduces friction and maintenance. It needs a control system and backup bearings.

What applications?

Data centers, district cooling and large centrifugals. Not for frequent starts or dirty power. Check the ride-through.

Related reading

For product specifications, see water chiller systems. For selection guides, visit the chiller knowledge base. Related articles: Imported vs Domestic Chillers: A Whole-Life Cost Comparison, Data Center Chiller Plant: Magnetic Bearings, N+1 and High-Temperature Chilled Water. To discuss a project, contact our engineering team. · Water Chiller Sizing · Chiller Part Load Selection · Chiller Plant Group Control

Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can review hourly load profiles, part-load efficiency and harmonic mitigation for magnetic-bearing chiller projects. For a project-specific configuration, contact 400-878-0280 or admin@longk.com.

Performance values and cost estimates are typical ranges; final selection must use manufacturer data, test reports and the project load calculation.