“Small uses scroll, medium uses screw, large uses centrifugal” is broadly true, but it hides the decision. At the same capacity, two compressor types may both work. What separates them is part-load behavior, wearing parts, noise and the maintenance capability of the site.
A 200 kW project can use four 50 kW scroll modules or one 200 kW screw unit. The scroll option may cost less, modulate better and tolerate a single module failure; the screw option is simpler, slightly more efficient at full load and takes less mechanical room space. Both are valid. The wrong choice usually comes from comparing only the quotation.
1. How the compressor motion shapes behavior
Piston. A crankshaft drives pistons in a reciprocating cycle: suction, compression, discharge. The technology is mature, tolerant of liquid slugging and high pressure, but has many moving parts: suction and discharge valves, piston rings, connecting-rod bearings. Wear in any of them affects efficiency. Vibration is higher and maintenance is more frequent.
Scroll. Two intermeshing scrolls orbit relative to each other, creating crescent-shaped pockets that move from the outside to the center. There are no suction or discharge valves, so the part count is low, vibration and noise are low, and efficiency is strong at small capacities. The limitation is the pressure ratio; capacity falls sharply in low-temperature duty. If the scrolls wear, the compressor is usually replaced rather than repaired on site.
Screw. A pair of intermeshing rotors compresses continuously. A slide valve or inverter adjusts capacity and internal volume ratio. It is compact, continuously variable and suited to long running hours. The oil system is more complex: oil separator, oil cooler and oil filter all need maintenance. At low load, an incorrect slide-valve position can cause over- or under-compression and efficiency loss.
| Type | Motion | Typical unit capacity | Capacity control | Main wearing parts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Piston | Reciprocating | 5–150 kW | Cylinder unloading, start/stop | Valves, rings, bearings |
| Scroll | Orbiting | 3–150 kW | Multiple heads, inverter, start/stop | Scrolls, bearings |
| Screw | Rotary | 150–1,500 kW | Slide valve, inverter | Bearings, shaft seal, oil filter |
2. Capacity ranges are economic, not technical
The textbook boundaries — scroll to 150 kW, screw from 150 kW — are economic boundaries, not hard limits. Scrolls can be paralleled to 600 kW; screw units can be built below 100 kW, but the economics are poor. Above roughly 300 kW, a scroll array needs more mechanical room space — often 30–50% more than a screw package — and the oil and control coordination becomes complex. Below 100 kW, a screw’s small rotors and relatively large clearances cause internal leakage, so efficiency falls below a good scroll.
| Capacity band | Common choice | Alternative | Decision point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Below 30 kW | Single scroll | Piston | Noise and installation |
| 30–150 kW | Scroll | Piston (low temperature) | Load variation; multiple heads |
| 150–300 kW | Scroll array / small screw | — | Capital vs mechanical room area |
| 300–800 kW | Screw | Scroll array | Long high-load hours |
| Above 800 kW | Centrifugal | Large screw | See screw vs centrifugal |
Condenser type also changes the answer. An air-cooled unit has a higher condensing temperature and pressure ratio, which weakens the scroll advantage. A water-cooled unit runs at a milder condition, where the scroll efficiency advantage is clearer.
3. Part load is the real separator
Most projects run at 40–70% load for most of the year; full-load hours are often below 10%. The three types behave very differently in that band.
| Load | Piston | Scroll array | Screw |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100% | Good | Good | Good |
| 75% | Fair (unloading) | Good | Good |
| 50% | Poor (start/stop) | Good | Fair |
| 25% | Poor | Fair with enough heads | Poor (slide-valve limit) |
Piston unloading is stepped — typically 100/75/50% — and below the last step it cycles. Frequent cycling causes water-temperature swings and high starting current. A scroll array can stage 25/50/75/100% and add inverter control for finer resolution, at the cost of more complex oil equalization and rotation logic. A screw with a slide valve is continuously variable from about 25–100%, but below 40% the fixed internal volume ratio no longer matches the pressure ratio, and efficiency falls. Long operation below 30% should use multiple heads or a smaller unit.
4. Noise and vibration
At 1 m, piston units are often 80–85 dB(A), screw units 75–80 dB(A), and scroll units 68–75 dB(A). The figures vary with model and fan configuration; use the sound-pressure spectrum, not a single dB number. Piston units need a rigid base and vibration isolation. Scroll units are easier to site near occupied spaces. Screw units need attention to oil-separator and pipe noise as well as the compressor.
If the mechanical room is under a residential building or inside a hospital, noise can be a veto criterion. In a standalone mechanical room with no sensitive neighbors, it carries less weight.
5. A 200 kW worked example
Duty: 200 kW, 2,000 equivalent full-load hours, 400,000 kWh cooling a year, electricity USD 0.09/kWh.
| Item | Four 50 kW scrolls | One 200 kW screw |
|---|---|---|
| Capital (example) | USD 53,000 | USD 61,000 |
| mechanical room area | About 60 m² | About 35 m² |
| IPLV (example) | 4.6 | 5.0 |
| Annual electricity | 87,000 kWh | 80,000 kWh |
| Annual energy cost | USD 7,830 | USD 7,200 |
| Annual saving | — | USD 630 |
The capital difference is USD 8,000; the annual saving is USD 630; simple payback is about 13 years. That is longer than half the equipment life. The screw choice does not pay back on energy alone at this size. It may still win if mechanical room area is a hard constraint, or if the load is very steady and the screw’s full-load efficiency is fully used.
At 600 kW and 3,000 hours, the picture changes: annual cooling is 1.8 million kWh, the annual electricity difference is about 31,000 kWh (USD 2,800), and a USD 11,000 capital difference pays back in about four years. The “boundary” is set by hours and tariffs, not by a fixed capacity number.
6. Four selection criteria
- Annual hours. Below 1,500 h, capital dominates; above 3,000 h, IPLV dominates.
- Load swing. If peak-to-average is more than 2:1, use multiple heads or inverter control; if near 1:1, a single screw is enough.
- Mechanical room. Tight area or low headroom favor screw; ample space and distributed placement favor scroll arrays.
- Maintenance capability. A site with refrigeration technicians can handle screw oil systems; an unmanned site should favor scroll, but budget for whole-compressor replacement.
7. Common questions
Is piston still used?
Yes, in low-temperature duty (evaporating below −25 °C), high-pressure-ratio process cooling, and small capacities where liquid-slug tolerance matters. In normal air-conditioning, scroll has largely replaced it because of parts count, maintenance and part-load performance.
Scroll array or single screw at 200 kW?
With normal tariffs and 2,000 hours, the scroll array is usually more economical. With very steady load, tight mechanical room and long hours, the screw can be the better choice.
Can a scroll compressor be repaired on site?
Usually not. Once the scrolls wear, the original clearance cannot be restored on site; the compressor or the whole unit is replaced. That is the hidden cost of a scroll array: low failure rate, high cost per failure.
Why is a screw inefficient at low load?
The slide valve changes the effective compression length, but the internal volume ratio does not follow the load continuously. Below about 40%, it no longer matches the pressure ratio, causing under- or over-compression. Multiple heads or inverter control improve it.
At 200 kW, which is easier to maintain: a scroll array or a screw?
A scroll array has lower first cost and better module redundancy, but a worn scroll compressor usually cannot be repaired on site; the compressor or unit is replaced. A screw has fewer compressors and is serviceable, but low-load efficiency falls below about 40%. Choose against the site's maintenance capability and load profile, not capacity alone.
Why does a screw chiller lose efficiency below 40%?
The slide valve changes the effective compression length, but the internal volume ratio does not follow the load continuously. Below about 40% it no longer matches the pressure ratio, causing under- or over-compression. Multiple heads or inverter control improve part-load behavior; check the actual curve for data-center duty.
Which compressor for 100–300 RT?
A screw for continuous duty and a scroll for smaller packaged units. A piston is for high pressure, not comfort cooling. Match the compressor to the load profile.
What part-load behavior?
Screw and scroll both unload, but the curve differs. Ask for the IPLV, not only the full-load COP. A poor part-load curve erases the full-load gain.
Related reading
For product specifications, see water chiller systems. For selection guides, visit the chiller knowledge base. Related articles: Imported vs Domestic Chillers: A Whole-Life Cost Comparison, Data Center Chiller Plant: Magnetic Bearings, N+1 and High-Temperature Chilled Water. To discuss a project, contact our engineering team. · Water Chiller Sizing · Chiller Part Load Selection · Chiller Plant Group Control
Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can compare compressor types on the actual load curve, mechanical room area and maintenance plan. Contact 400-878-0280 or admin@longk.com with the cooling load profile.
Capacities, prices and efficiency figures are examples for comparison; final selection must use manufacturer data, local tariffs and the project load curve.