Efficiency loss is different from a breakdown. A breakdown alarms; efficiency loss does not. Product moisture creeps up month by month, or a unit rated at 8 t/d now handles 6 t/d, while the motor keeps running and the electricity bill stays high. By the time the operator notices, the condenser may be badly scaled or the fan worn to its limit.
The practical method is to quantify the loss first, then read five measurements, then work through the system from the air path inward. This article sets out that sequence for a heat-pump low-temperature sludge dryer.
Values are typical ranges; use the manufacturer’s data and the site’s operating records.
1. Quantify the loss
“It feels slower” is not a measurement. Convert the loss into three numbers: evaporation rate, unit power and product moisture.
Evaporation = feed rate × (feed moisture − product moisture) ÷ (1 − product moisture). For 10 t/d, 80% feed and 30% product: 10 × (0.80 − 0.30) ÷ (1 − 0.30) = 7.14 t/d. If product moisture rises to 40%: 10 × (0.80 − 0.40) ÷ (1 − 0.40) = 6.67 t/d. Evaporation falls 6.6%, but unit power can rise more than 15% because the same fan and compressor are drying less water.
| Product moisture | Evaporation | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 30% | 7.14 t/d | — |
| 35% | 6.92 t/d | −3.1% |
| 40% | 6.67 t/d | −6.6% |
| 45% | 6.36 t/d | −10.9% |
2. Five measurements to take first
Record five values at the same load and the same feed moisture, or the comparison is meaningless:
Feed rate and feed moisture. A 3-point rise in feed moisture adds evaporation load without any change in the dryer.
Product moisture. Sample across the discharge outlet, not from one point; a sticky belt can deliver wet lumps that bias a single sample.
Condensate flow. Compare with the calculated evaporation. A lower flow means less water is being removed, or the condensate is bypassing the meter.
Unit power. kWh per metric ton of water evaporated. Normal for heat-pump low-temperature drying is 22–32 kWh/t water; above 35 kWh/t sustained indicates a problem.
Air and refrigerant temperatures. Supply air, return air, evaporating temperature and condensing temperature. These show whether the issue is airflow, heat transfer or charge.
Most controllers already display these values; no extra instruments are needed for the first pass.
3. Nine causes, in frequency order
The first four account for most cases, and all four develop gradually.
| Order | Cause | Indicator | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Finned coil fouling | Fan current falls, air flow drops | Clean coils |
| 2 | Condenser scaling | High condensing pressure, poor supply air | Descale or clean |
| 3 | Fan wear or imbalance | Noise rises, flow below 85% design | Service or replace |
| 4 | Filter blockage | Cabinet negative pressure rises | Clean or replace |
| 5 | Low refrigerant charge | Superheat above 8 K, high discharge | Leak test, then charge |
| 6 | Expansion valve sticking | Hunting superheat, uneven frost | Clean or replace valve |
| 7 | Water-side fouling | Water ΔT falls at same flow | Chemical or mechanical cleaning |
| 8 | Sludge change | Higher shear, lower drainability | Adjust dewatering or conditioning |
| 9 | Bed thickness or speed | Thick bed, short residence | Restore recipe |
4. Work through the system
Air path. Check the filter, coil and fan first; these can be inspected without stopping the unit. A blocked filter shows as higher cabinet negative pressure and lower recirculation flow. Clean the filter according to the environment: every three months in a clean room, monthly in a dusty site. Coil fouling is less visible: a 1.4 mm fin pitch can lose 30% of its open area in three months in a dusty plant. Measure fan current at the same speed; falling current means higher resistance and lower flow. A fan that has run for more than two years may have worn blades or dry bearings; if measured flow is below 85% of design, service the fan before looking at the heat exchanger.
Refrigerant side. Low charge and a stuck expansion valve both lower suction pressure, but they differ in superheat. Low charge gives consistently high superheat (above 8 K), high discharge temperature and bubbles in the sight glass. Find and repair the leak first; then charge to the nameplate value. A sticking valve gives hunting superheat and uneven frost across circuits — one circuit frosted, another clear. Clean the valve strainer first; replace the valve if it still hunts.
Water side. If the unit has a water-cooled condenser, a falling water-side ΔT at the same flow indicates fouling. A design ΔT of 5 K that falls to 2–3 K means the heat-transfer coefficient has dropped. Scale of 0.3 mm can reduce it by about 10%, raise condensing temperature by 1.5 K and increase power by 3–4%. Clean chemically or mechanically, then compare the ΔT with the commissioning record.
Material side. Sludge changes are often overlooked. A different polymer, a changed dewatering press setting or a different cake can alter shear and water retention, changing drying speed by up to 20%. Take a sample, measure moisture and drainage, and compare with the commissioning sample. If feed moisture rises by 3 points, fix the dewatering first; do not adjust the dryer recipe. Bed thickness matters too: increasing from 20 mm to 35 mm can almost double drying time. Some plants speed up the feed to raise throughput, but product moisture rises and total evaporation falls.
5. Three cautions
High condensing pressure is not always a water-side problem. Low circulation air also raises it because heat cannot leave the condenser. Check airflow before water quality.
High product moisture is not always insufficient heat. Product may stick to the belt and sample as wet surface material. Sample across the discharge cross-section, not from one point.
Efficiency loss may be seasonal. In winter, a heat-pump dryer’s COP falls with ambient temperature. Correct for ambient before comparing; otherwise every winter looks like a new problem.
6. Verify the fix
After each intervention, run for four hours before sampling; the first two hours still reflect the old condition. Then repeat the same five measurements and compare. Unit power should return below 30 kWh/t water, and product moisture should be within ±3 points of setpoint. Record the date, action and before/after values. The log shows how long each measure lasts — for example, how many months a coil cleaning buys — and tells you when to schedule the next one.
7. Boundaries
This sequence is for heat-pump low-temperature dryers. Belt hot-air, paddle and disc dryers have different measurements and a different order. Calibrate pressure and temperature sensors annually; a 3% drift can mislead the diagnosis. Refrigerant work requires qualified personnel. A unit that has had a compressor or heat exchanger replaced needs a new baseline; old data is no longer a valid comparison.
Frequently asked questions
What are the five measurements?
Evaporation rate, unit power per metric ton of water, air pressure drop, refrigerant approach and sludge feed moisture. These separate an air-path problem from a refrigerant, water-side or feed problem. Take them at the same load and ambient condition.
How is evaporation measured?
Weigh the feed and product over a timed run, measure moisture by drying, and calculate water removed. Do not rely on the display. A small change in feed moisture can look like a large capacity loss.
What does unit power show?
Kilowatt-hours per metric ton of water removed. If it rises while evaporation falls, the dryer is working harder for less water. Compare with the commissioning baseline at the same ambient and feed.
Why check air pressure drop?
A rising drop across filters, coils or the bed means blockage. Reduced airflow lowers evaporation and can raise compressor head. Clean or replace the filter and inspect the coil before touching the refrigerant circuit.
What does refrigerant approach indicate?
Approach is the condensing or evaporating temperature difference to the water or air. A rising approach suggests fouling, non-condensables or low charge. Read it with subcooling and superheat to distinguish the cause.
What water-side checks matter?
Flow, inlet and outlet temperature, strainer, pump and valve position. Low flow raises approach and reduces capacity. A bypassing valve can make the chiller look oversized or underloaded.
How does sludge quality affect capacity?
Higher moisture, higher viscosity, oil or salt can slow drying and cause sticking. Compare the current sludge with the design sludge. A new source may need return mixing or a lower throughput, not a new compressor.
How is performance restored?
Fix the first constraining item, then re-test. Cleaning the air path and condenser often restores most of the loss. Only then evaluate refrigerant charge, controls and mechanical condition.
Related reading
Municipal sludge drying · Sludge moisture reduction calculation · Dried sludge disposal