Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Heat pump · Hot water · Heating · Cooling

Cold-Climate Air-Source Heat Pumps: Capacity, COP and Defrost Losses

“Rated to −25 °C” is one of the most misleading claims in the heat-pump market. A unit may keep running at −25 °C while delivering half its nominal capacity and a COP below 2.0, with electric resistance heat doing the real work. That is not a cold-climate heat pump; it is a unit that does not trip.

Real cold-climate capability is shown by a capacity and COP curve at the actual design temperature and flow temperature, not by a single minimum operating temperature.

1. Why capacity falls: pressure ratio and volumetric efficiency

The root cause is the pressure ratio: condensing pressure divided by evaporating pressure. At −20 °C outdoor air, the evaporating temperature may be around −30 °C to absorb heat, so evaporating pressure falls sharply. For 55 °C supply water, condensing temperature is about 60 °C and condensing pressure stays roughly the same. The ratio can rise from about 3 in mild weather to more than 6 in deep cold.

Two things follow. First, volumetric efficiency falls: high-pressure gas trapped in the compressor clearance volume expands before suction, reducing the mass flow. A ratio rise from 3 to 6 can cut volumetric efficiency from about 85% to 60%. Second, discharge temperature rises; above the limit, the unit trips on protection, and lubricant thinning accelerates wear.

Outdoor temperature Evaporating temperature Pressure ratio (example) Volumetric efficiency Relative capacity
7 °C 0 °C About 3.0 About 85% 100%
−7 °C −15 °C About 4.2 About 75% 78–85%
−15 °C −25 °C About 5.3 About 65% 60–70%
−25 °C −35 °C About 6.5 About 55% 45–55%

The loss is thermodynamics, not poor manufacturing. The difference between suppliers is how well they control the loss and how long they can maintain a usable COP.

2. Three technical routes

Vapor injection (EVI). A branch of medium-pressure refrigerant is injected into the compression process. This lowers discharge temperature and increases refrigerant mass flow, so the compressor can maintain capacity at a high pressure ratio. At −15 °C, heating capacity typically rises 20–30% and discharge temperature falls 10–20 K. EVI is the mainstream cold-climate solution.

Inverter compressors. Higher speed compensates for lower volumetric efficiency. Inverters also match load well and improve part-load efficiency. The limit is shaft speed and the friction and discharge temperature that come with it; inverters alone do not solve deep cold. They are usually combined with EVI.

Two-stage compression. The compression is split into two stages with intercooling, keeping each stage’s ratio within a reasonable range. It gives the best cold-climate performance but is complex and expensive; it is used mainly below −30 °C or in special industrial duty.

Route Cold-climate gain Cost Typical range
EVI Capacity +20–30% Medium −15 to −25 °C
Inverter Better part-load efficiency Medium −10 to −20 °C
Two-stage Best High Below −25 °C

Ask for measured data at the design condition. “Uses EVI” is not evidence; compressor design, coil area and control strategy all change the result.

3. Separate “can run” from “can save”

The key figure is cold-climate COP. A good curve degrades gently. With 55 °C supply water, a conventional unit may reach COP 4.0 at 7 °C, 2.6 at −7 °C, 2.0 at −15 °C and 1.5 at −25 °C. An EVI unit might reach 4.2, 3.2, 2.6 and 2.1. The gap widens as it gets colder.

Outdoor temperature Conventional COP EVI COP Saving vs electric heat
7 °C 4.0 4.2 About 75%
−7 °C 2.6 3.2 62–69%
−15 °C 2.0 2.6 50–62%
−25 °C 1.5 2.1 33–52%

Below COP 2.0, the advantage over electric resistance is small. If the deep-cold period lasts only a few dozen hours a year, a large cold-climate unit may never pay back; a small resistance backup can be the cheaper design. The value of cold-climate equipment depends on the number of hours at low temperature, not on the lowest number in the brochure.

Supply temperature also matters. At the same −15 °C outdoor, COP at 45 °C supply is about 20–25% higher than at 55 °C. Underfloor heating and fan coils are therefore a better match than high-temperature radiators. High-temperature domestic hot water needs a different design.

4. Defrost is a real load

In cold, humid weather, frost forms on the coil when the surface is below both dew point and freezing. The unit reverses the cycle to melt it, typically for 3–8 minutes. During defrost it does not heat, and it consumes heat from the water side. In cold-humid regions, defrost losses can be 8–15% of winter energy.

Condition Frost severity Defrost loss Recommendation
−10 to 5 °C, high humidity Heavy 8–15% Demand-based defrost
Below −15 °C, low humidity Light < 5% Timed defrost acceptable
Above 5 °C None 0 No defrost

Add defrost loss to the sizing margin. If winter defrost loss is 12%, the nominal capacity should be about 1.12 times the design load. Many “works in the day but drops at night” complaints come from ignoring this line.

5. Five-step cold-climate selection

  1. Set the design outdoor temperature. Use the local winter design condition, not the all-time extreme. An extreme that lasts a few hours should not size the plant for the whole year.
  2. Get capacity at that condition. Require capacity and COP at the design outdoor temperature and actual supply temperature. Nominal data is not acceptable.
  3. Apply corrections. Divide the design load by cold-climate capacity, then multiply by 1.08–1.15 for defrost. Check whether a small resistance backup is cheaper than another size step.
  4. Check the water side. Low flow increases freezing risk. Keep minimum circulation, insulate and trace outdoor pipes, and write a freeze-protection sequence into the controller.
  5. Calculate annual energy. Use hour-by-hour COP and the number of hours at each temperature. Then judge whether the cold-climate premium pays back.

6. A cold-climate specification sheet

A “−25 °C” label is not a selection basis. The specification should force the supplier to state what the unit does at the site’s design condition, with the water temperature and defrost penalty included.

Field Example entry Why it matters
Design outdoor temperature −18 °C, with the number of hours below −15 °C Sets the capacity and COP that must be met; an all-time extreme that lasts two hours should not size the plant.
Supply and return water 55/45 °C, or the actual design COP depends on the lift; a 45 °C supply can be 20%–25% better than 55 °C.
Capacity at design condition kW, with the datasheet page and test condition Nominal capacity at 7 °C is irrelevant to a cold-climate load.
COP at design condition Unit and value, with the outdoor and water temperatures Separates “can run” from “can save”; below COP 2 the resistance-backup case may be cheaper.
Defrost loss % of winter energy, and the defrost control strategy Adds 8%–15% to the required capacity in cold-humid regions.
Backup and control Resistance kW, lockout sequence, freeze protection Defines what happens at the design condition and during a power failure.

Attach the manufacturer’s low-temperature curve to the tender return. A supplier that cannot provide capacity and COP at the design condition has not quoted a cold-climate product; it has quoted a unit with a minimum operating temperature.

7. Common questions

Is a −25 °C rating enough for a cold region?

No. It only says the unit will not stop. Ask for capacity and COP at −25 °C. If capacity is half of nominal and COP is below 2, resistance heat is doing the work.

Is EVI essential?

For most regions below −15 °C, yes. It maintains mass flow and lowers discharge temperature. But implementation matters; ask for measured low-temperature data, not just the technology name.

Why add freeze protection if the heat pump runs?

The unit running does not protect outdoor pipes or the water side. Keep minimum flow, insulate and trace exposed lines, and define what happens on a stop or power failure.

How large is defrost loss?

Typically 8–15% of winter energy in cold-humid regions. Demand-based defrost reduces unnecessary cycles; include the loss in capacity margin rather than ignoring it.

How much electric backup heat is appropriate?

Use backup for the deficit at the design outdoor temperature, not for the whole load. Size the heat pump on capacity at design condition plus an 8–15% defrost margin; if the deep-cold period lasts only a few dozen hours, a small resistance backup is cheaper than another size step. Above that, compare a larger EVI unit on annual energy.

What causes freezing risk besides low ambient temperature?

Low water flow is the main one: it lowers the evaporating temperature and can freeze the exchanger. Keep minimum circulation, insulate and trace outdoor pipes, and define freeze protection for a stop or power failure. Defrost also takes heat from the water side, so the loop needs enough volume and temperature stability.

What capacity at -20 °C?

Expect 50–65% of the rated capacity, depending on the model. Defrost and low suction reduce output. Use the site condition, not the catalog.

What defrost?

Frost builds on the coil and blocks airflow. A reverse-cycle or hot-gas defrost adds load. Size for the defrost penalty.

Related reading

For product specifications, see air-source heat pump systems. For selection guides, visit the heat-pump knowledge base. Related articles: Air-Source vs Ground-Source Heat Pumps for Hot Water: When the Extra Boreholes Pay Back, Can High-Temperature Heat Pumps Replace a Steam Boiler?. To discuss a project, contact our engineering team. · Heat Pump Commissioning Checklist · Heat Pump Project Questions · Heat Pump Price Factors

Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can review cold-climate capacity curves, defrost loss and backup heat for a specific location. Contact 400-878-0280 or admin@longk.com with the winter design condition and daily hot-water demand.

Capacity, COP and defrost figures are typical ranges; final selection must use manufacturer test data, local meteorological data and the actual water circuit.