Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Industrial cooling · Process

Cooling Tower Selection for Water-Cooled Chillers: Heat Rejection, Approach and Water Quality

A cooling tower is not selected from the chiller’s nominal cooling capacity alone. The tower must reject the condenser heat, which is the cooling capacity plus the compressor power. A 500 kW chiller with a COP of 5.0 rejects about 600 kW; the same chiller at a COP of 4.0 rejects about 625 kW. The tower, the cooling-water pump and the pipework all follow that heat rejection figure.

The second common error is to treat water treatment as an optional extra. An open cooling circuit concentrates dissolved solids as water evaporates. Scale, corrosion and microbiological growth follow, and the condenser approach temperature rises until the chiller trips on high pressure. Many manufacturers exclude heat-exchanger damage caused by untreated water from warranty cover.

This article sets out the heat balance, tower selection, water balance, hydraulic details and maintenance intervals. The worked example is illustrative, not a quotation.

1. Heat rejection and water flow

Condenser heat. For a water-cooled chiller:

Q_rej = Q_evap + P_compressor.

At a COP of 5.0, the compressor power is 20% of the cooling capacity, so the heat rejection is 1.2 × the cooling capacity. At a COP of 4.0, it is 1.25 ×. Use the manufacturer’s heat-rejection table for the actual model and operating point.

Example. 500 kW cooling at a COP of 5.0 gives about 600 kW rejection. With a 5 K cooling-water rise:

mass flow = 600 ÷ (4.187 × 5) ≈ 28.7 kg/s, or about 103 m³/h.

A useful planning rule is 0.19–0.21 m³/h per kW of cooling capacity at a 5 K rise and a COP near 5. The exact figure follows the heat rejection and the selected ΔT.

Cooling capacity COP Heat rejection Flow at ΔT 5 K
100 kW 5.0 120 kW 20.6 m³/h
300 kW 5.0 360 kW 61.9 m³/h
500 kW 5.0 600 kW 103 m³/h
500 kW 4.0 625 kW 107 m³/h

2. Tower selection: wet bulb, approach and range

Wet-bulb temperature. The tower’s leaving water temperature is limited by the ambient wet bulb, not the dry bulb. A tower with a 4 K approach at a 28 °C design wet bulb produces 32 °C water. If the wet bulb rises to 30 °C, the same tower produces 34 °C; the chiller’s condensing temperature rises and capacity falls. Use the local design wet bulb, not the average summer dry-bulb.

Approach. Approach is the difference between leaving water and entering wet bulb. Comfort chillers normally use 3–5 K. A smaller approach needs more fill, more air or a larger tower; a larger approach saves capital but raises condensing temperature and compressor power. The trade-off should be evaluated over the operating hours, not only at the design point.

Range. Range is the cooling-water temperature drop, normally 5 K. A wider range reduces flow and pump energy but may reduce the tower’s thermal performance; check the manufacturer’s selection curves.

Capacity rating. Towers are rated at a specific flow, range, wet bulb and approach. Do not compare nominal “tons” across manufacturers without converting to the same conditions. Ask for a selection printout at the project’s design wet bulb.

Parameter Typical value Effect
Design wet bulb Local 5% summer value Sets the minimum leaving water temperature
Approach 3–5 K Smaller approach: larger tower, lower condensing temperature
Range 5 K Wider range reduces flow but changes selection
Drift loss 0.005–0.02% of flow Affects makeup and plume
Fan power 0.01–0.03 kW per kW rejection Variable-speed fans save at part load

3. Water balance and treatment

Evaporation. A practical estimate is:

E = flow × range ÷ 580, in the same units.

For 100 m³/h and a 5 K range, E ≈ 0.86 m³/h. About 1% of the flow evaporates for every 5 K of cooling.

Cycles of concentration. If dissolved solids are allowed to concentrate four times before blowdown, the blowdown is:

B = E ÷ (COC − 1) = 0.86 ÷ 3 ≈ 0.29 m³/h.

Makeup is E + B ≈ 1.15 m³/h. At two cycles, blowdown equals evaporation and makeup doubles; water and chemical consumption rise sharply. Four to six cycles is a common target, provided the makeup water chemistry allows it.

Scale. Calcium and magnesium salts deposit on the condenser tube wall. A 0.2 mm scale layer can raise energy consumption by several percent and push the condensing temperature up. Control it with softening, antiscalant and blowdown; clean mechanically or chemically when the approach temperature rises.

Corrosion. Dissolved oxygen and acidic conditions pit carbon steel and copper. Use corrosion inhibitors, keep the pH in the supplier’s range and avoid dead legs where deposits collect.

Microbiological growth. Warm, wet fill is an ideal habitat. Biocides and periodic cleaning control biofilm, which otherwise insulates the tube and accelerates under-deposit corrosion. Legionella risk also requires a documented water-management plan.

Item Formula or target Example at 100 m³/h, 5 K
Evaporation Flow × range ÷ 580 0.86 m³/h
Blowdown at 4 cycles E ÷ (4 − 1) 0.29 m³/h
Makeup E + B 1.15 m³/h
Condenser approach 1–3 K when clean Record monthly
Water treatment Scale, corrosion, biocide Monthly test; quarterly review

4. Hydraulics and installation

Independent supports. The cooling-water pipework must have its own supports. Do not hang it from the chiller or the tower structure. Pipe weight and thermal movement can distort the condenser connections.

Flexible joints and valves. Fit flexible connectors at the chiller and tower connections, isolation valves for maintenance, thermometers and pressure gauges at the inlet and outlet, and a strainer before the condenser. A flow switch or differential pressure switch protects the chiller from running dry.

Air and filling. The cooling circuit needs an air vent at the high point and a drain at the low point. The tower basin should be sized for the fill volume and for pump start-up, with a make-up valve and overflow.

Bypass and equalization. For multiple cells, equalize the basins or use a common sump. A bypass around the tower allows testing and maintenance without stopping the chiller. Check that the pump suction is flooded; a tower located above the pump needs a priming arrangement.

Freeze protection. In cold climates, the basin, makeup line and exposed pipe need heat tracing or draining. A frozen basin in winter can crack the fill and stop the plant.

5. High-pressure alarms and cleaning

A high-pressure trip is usually a cooling-side problem, not a refrigerant problem. Check in this order: cooling-water flow, tower fan operation, fill condition, water temperature, condenser approach and refrigerant charge. Refrigerant overcharge and non-condensable gas are possible, but they are less common than a fouled condenser or a failed fan.

Cleaning. Shell-and-tube condensers can be cleaned mechanically with brushes or plugs, or chemically with a weak acid. After chemical cleaning, neutralize and flush thoroughly. Air-cooled fin coils are cleaned with compressed air or a low-pressure water jet from the inside out, without bending the fins.

Frequency. Good water quality with treatment: annually. Poor water or an open tower: every six months. Clean the tower fill and basin at the same time; cleaning only the condenser leaves the biofilm source in place.

6. Air-cooled or water-cooled?

Air-cooled chillers reject heat directly to air and need no tower or cooling-water pump. They suit water-scarce sites, small projects and buildings without space for a tower. Their condensing temperature follows the ambient dry bulb, so capacity and COP fall on hot afternoons, and the condenser fans add noise.

Water-cooled chillers have a more stable condensing temperature, a COP typically 20–30% higher at the same nominal capacity, and can be built in larger sizes. They need a tower, cooling-water pump, water treatment and more maintenance. The choice depends on capacity, water availability, space, climate and the owner’s ability to operate a water system.

Factor Air-cooled Water-cooled
Heat rejection Direct to air Tower to air
COP at design Lower; falls with dry bulb Higher and more stable
Water use None Evaporation, blowdown, makeup
Footprint Large condenser area Mechanical room plus tower
Maintenance Coil cleaning Coil, tower, water treatment
Best fit Small or water-scarce Medium and large; stable load

7. Common questions

Does a water-cooled chiller always need a cooling tower?

Yes, unless it rejects to a river, lake or district cooling loop under a valid permit. The tower can be remote or on a roof, but the condenser needs a continuous flow of cooling water at the design temperature.

How is tower size calculated?

Start from condenser heat rejection, not nominal cooling capacity. For 500 kW cooling at COP 5, reject about 600 kW and flow about 103 m³/h at ΔT 5 K. Then select a tower that delivers the required approach at the local design wet bulb.

Why does the chiller trip on high pressure in summer?

Most often the cooling water is too warm or the flow is low: undersized tower, failed fan, clogged fill or a fouled condenser. Check the approach temperature and flow before adding refrigerant.

How often should the condenser be cleaned?

Annually with good water treatment; every six months with poor water or an open tower. Clean when the approach temperature rises, not only on a calendar. Clean the fill and basin at the same time.

Can groundwater be used?

Only with the required abstraction permit and a water analysis. Groundwater is often hard or corrosive and may need treatment; many regions restrict abstraction. A closed circuit with a tower is usually more manageable.

How much water does a tower consume?

At 100 m³/h and 5 K, evaporation is about 0.86 m³/h; at four cycles, blowdown is about 0.29 m³/h, so makeup is about 1.15 m³/h. Actual consumption depends on load, climate and cycles.

Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can check condenser heat rejection, select towers at the project wet bulb, and review water treatment and hydraulic design. Send the chiller schedule and local weather data to admin@longk.com or call 400-878-0280.

Heat rejection, flow and water-balance figures are illustrative. Final selection must use the manufacturer’s performance data, local design wet bulb and water analysis.

What approach should I specify?

3–5 K at design wet bulb. A tighter approach needs a bigger tower and more fan power. Do not specify below 2 K.

What range and flow?

Design the range with the chiller condenser. A 5 K range is common; a lower range needs more flow and pump power.

Related reading

Water Chiller Sizing · Chiller Part Load Selection · Chiller Plant Group Control