“What grade is it?” is a standard chiller question, and one of the most misused. An efficiency label is not a ranking of annual savings. It is a market-entry threshold, a grading method and a labeling rule. It does not evaluate installation quality, system efficiency or whether the unit will save money at your duty.
GB 19577-2024 is the current mandatory energy-efficiency standard for water chillers, replacing the 2015 edition. Use the current edition for tenders and efficiency review; do not assume an old test report is still accepted.
1. What the standard covers — and what it does not
It covers three things: minimum allowable efficiency values, efficiency grades (usually three, with grade 1 the highest and grade 3 the threshold), and the test, registration and labeling requirements.
It does not cover: system efficiency (chilled-water pumps, cooling-water pumps and cooling towers are outside its boundary); actual operating efficiency at your load profile; or installation and commissioning quality, which belongs to the installation and acceptance standards.
The consequence is direct: a grade-1 chiller in a hydraulically unbalanced system with oversized pumps can have a worse system efficiency than a grade-3 chiller in a well-designed plant. The standard is not wrong; the user has crossed its boundary. Keep chiller efficiency and system efficiency as separate lines in any energy assessment.
2. COP and IPLV divide the job
| Metric | Test condition | What it reflects | Best used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| COP | Nominal full load | Hardware design: compressor, exchanger area, approach temperature | Peak capability; extreme-weather efficiency |
| IPLV | Weighted 100/75/50/25% points | Part-load control and efficiency | Annual running cost |
| System efficiency | Includes pumps and tower | Whole-plant design quality | The electricity bill |
COP is full-load efficiency. IPLV is a weighted part-load figure; the weights sit mainly at 75% and 50%, where most operating hours fall. A unit can have a high COP but a modest IPLV — for example, a fixed-speed single-head machine that can only cycle at 50% load. Another unit can have a moderate COP but a strong IPLV and be cheaper to run all year. If the project spends most hours at 50–70% load, IPLV is the more relevant number; COP still checks peak capability.
3. Why capacity bands change the grade
The standard sets thresholds by category: condenser type (air-cooled, water-cooled, evaporative), compressor type (scroll, screw, centrifugal) and capacity band. The reason is physical. An air-cooled unit has a higher condensing temperature and a lower COP than a water-cooled unit. A small scroll has less exchanger area than a large centrifugal. A single threshold would exclude every small air-cooled model.
| Category | Typical capacity | Relative efficiency | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Air-cooled scroll | 10–120 kW | Lower | Small loads; water-scarce sites |
| Air-cooled screw | 100–500 kW | Medium | Medium projects; no cooling tower |
| Water-cooled screw | 200–1,000 kW | Higher | Mainstream central plants |
| Water-cooled centrifugal | 500–3,000 kW | High | Large, long-hour loads |
Always read the grade with the category. A “grade-1 air-cooled scroll” and a “grade-3 water-cooled centrifugal” are not comparable; the air-cooled COP may still be lower. That is not a contradiction; it is a different category.
4. Verify the label
A label carries four items: grade, COP and IPLV values, the standard number and edition, and the registration number. Check in this order:
- Edition. Is it the current GB 19577-2024? An old-edition label may not be accepted in an energy review.
- Consistency. Do the label, datasheet and tender submission show exactly the same values? A difference in one decimal place is a documentation inconsistency.
- Registration. Verify the registration number on the energy-label platform.
A common problem is three different IPLV numbers: the tender says 6.8, the brochure says 6.5 at 50% load, and the registration shows another value. The registered value governs; ask the manufacturer to explain the test condition in writing. This is a documentation issue, but it can disqualify a bid.
5. Worked example: one grade, what does it save?
Duty: 800 kW, 2,500 equivalent full-load hours, 2,000,000 kWh cooling a year, electricity USD 0.09/kWh.
| Case | COP | Annual electricity | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grade 1 (example) | 5.8 | 344,800 kWh | USD 31,030 |
| Grade 3 (example) | 5.2 | 384,600 kWh | USD 34,610 |
| Difference | 0.6 | 39,800 kWh | USD 3,580 |
Using IPLV instead: IPLV 6.5 gives about 307,700 kWh; IPLV 5.6 gives about 357,100 kWh; the difference is 49,400 kWh, or about USD 4,450 a year. The two methods differ because they examine different conditions; actual operation lies between them, and IPLV is usually closer for a variable-load project.
If the grade-1 unit costs USD 21,000 more, the simple payback is about five years. If it costs USD 42,000 more, payback is about ten years — longer than the economic life for many projects. In that case, the better investment may be pump inverters and plant-level controls, not a higher chiller grade.
6. Tender wording that makes the label enforceable
Set the grade and the values. “The unit shall be at least grade 2 to GB 19577-2024, with nominal COP not lower than X and IPLV not lower than Y at the contract condition.” Fill in project-specific values, not the brochure’s best number.
Set verification. “At delivery, verify the label and registration; at commissioning, measure the efficiency at the specified points; the measured value shall be at least 95% of the datasheet value.” This turns a paper number into a testable requirement.
Set the consequence. “If measured performance is below the agreed value, the supplier shall rectify within a defined period; if it still fails, the contract remedies apply.” Without this clause, the first two are statements of intent.
7. Five common misunderstandings
- Higher grade always means lower bills. It depends on the match between efficiency and load profile. A high-grade chiller running at 30% load may not realize its advantage.
- COP alone is enough. Annual cost is driven by part load; ignoring IPLV underestimates the value of good unloading.
- An old report is acceptable. After a standard revision, old reports may not be accepted. Check the edition before bidding.
- Passing the threshold means “energy-saving”. Grade 3 is the market-entry threshold, not a savings guarantee. Efficient projects usually specify grade 2 or better and check system efficiency.
- Conditions do not matter. Cooling water at 30/35 °C and 32/37 °C are different duties; COP can differ by 4–6%. State the condition in the datasheet and the contract.
8. Commissioning test points that prove the label
A label is a declaration at standard conditions. The contract needs a test that shows the delivered machine meets the declared values at the project’s conditions. Specify the points, the instruments and the acceptance rule before the bid is awarded.
| Test point | Load | Record | Acceptance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full load | 100% | Capacity, input power, COP, leaving/entering water, condenser water | COP not below the contract value after correction to design conditions. |
| Part load 1 | 75% | Same set, plus compressor speed or stage | Within the IPLV point tolerance and the datasheet curve. |
| Part load 2 | 50% | Same set; record stability over 30 minutes | No hunting, no short cycling, and IPLV contribution within tolerance. |
| Part load 3 | 25% | Same set; minimum load and unloading behavior | Stable operation at the lowest specified load without surge or trip. |
| Correction | — | Ambient, barometric pressure, water flow, fouling factor | Correction method agreed in writing before the test. |
| Documentation | — | Calibrated instrument certificates, raw data, test standard | Records traceable to the model and serial number. |
A measured value at or above 95% of the datasheet value is a common acceptance threshold, but the contract should state it. Without a correction method and calibrated instruments, a commissioning test becomes another opinion rather than evidence.
9. Common questions
Can a grade-3 chiller still be purchased?
Yes. Grade 3 is the legal threshold. But its annual energy cost is higher; it suits very low hours, a hard budget cap, or a plant with a planned later upgrade.
COP or IPLV — which is more important?
For continuous full-load duty such as process cooling or data centers, COP matters; for offices, hotels and variable loads, IPLV matters. Most projects should select on IPLV and check COP for peak capability.
What if the label and nameplate do not match?
Ask for a written explanation and check the registration. The registered value governs; keep the evidence for acceptance. If the registered value is below the contract requirement, treat it as a performance non-conformity, not a labeling detail.
Does an inverter unit get a single IPLV?
It should be tested across its modulation range at the specified load points, not only at full load. Ask for point-by-point data; a single number cannot prove part-load capability.
Does a grade-1 label guarantee a lower bill?
No. The grade is a market-entry and grading result at standard conditions, not a prediction of annual saving. The bill depends on the load profile, hours, part-load performance, installation and system efficiency. Compare annual kWh at the actual duty, and check COP for peak capability.
What tender wording makes the efficiency enforceable?
Require the specific model and its registered value at the contract condition, COP and IPLV at stated load points, the test standard and registration evidence. Add a performance non-conformity clause and require label/nameplate verification at acceptance; a grade alone is not enforceable.
What does GB 19577 cover?
It sets efficiency grades for chillers and the label values. It does not guarantee system savings.
What should a tender ask?
The grade, the test standard and the part-load value. A grade alone does not prove the plant performance.
Related reading
For product specifications, see water chiller systems. For selection guides, visit the chiller knowledge base. Related articles: Imported vs Domestic Chillers: A Whole-Life Cost Comparison, Data Center Chiller Plant: Magnetic Bearings, N+1 and High-Temperature Chilled Water. To discuss a project, contact our engineering team. · Water Chiller Sizing · Chiller Part Load Selection · Chiller Plant Group Control
Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can help prepare chiller efficiency clauses, compare grades at the actual load profile and check label documentation. Contact 400-878-0280 or admin@longk.com.
Limit values, categories and test methods must follow the current GB 19577-2024 text and its referenced standards; the figures above are illustrative.