A chiller bid can run to hundreds of pages, but the technical evaluation usually starts with a single table. The evaluator reads the requirement, the bid value and the evidence in sequence. If the value has no condition, or the condition has no report, the bid is sent for clarification or marked non-responsive.
The response table is not a copy of the catalog. It is an alignment of three things: the tender requirement, the offered model’s value at the same condition, and the document that proves it.
1. The three-part response
Every row should answer: what is the value, at what condition, and where is the evidence. A response that says “meets” without a number fails the first question. A number without a condition fails the second. A number with a condition but no page reference fails the third.
| Item | Tender requirement | Bid response | Deviation | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nominal capacity | ≥ 1,200 kW | 1,250 kW at 7/12 °C, 32/37 °C | +4.2% | Catalog page 12, selection report |
| IPLV | ≥ 6.0 | 6.3 | +5.0% | Efficiency test report |
| Water resistance | ≤ 80 kPa | 76 kPa at rated flow | None | Hydraulic calculation |
| Noise | ≤ 80 dB(A) at 1 m | 78 dB(A) | +2 dB margin | Test report |
| Refrigerant | R134a | R513A | Negative | Alternative statement, efficiency comparison |
| Starting current | ≤ 3× rated | 2.6× with soft starter | +0.4× margin | Electrical schematic |
The refrigerant row is the model case. R513A may be accepted, but only if the bid states the efficiency, safety, charge and service implications. A “complies” entry with a different refrigerant is a hidden negative deviation, and evaluators treat hidden deviations as a credibility problem.
2. Star clauses and ordinary clauses
A clause marked with a star or triangle is usually pass/fail. Respond to each one on its own line; do not write “all of the above are met”. A single missed star clause can end the technical evaluation before the commercial score is opened.
Ordinary clauses may allow a limited number of negative deviations, often three and only if the function is unaffected. Count the deviations before submitting. If the count exceeds the limit, change the model or the configuration rather than hope the evaluator will not notice.
One clause is often overlooked: “the test report shall be for the same model”. A report for a model with a different suffix is not the same model. Check the model, the report number and the efficiency grade as a set.
3. Six common rejection paths
| Path | What it looks like | How to avoid it |
|---|---|---|
| Star clause unanswered | “Meets” with no number | One row per star clause, value and page |
| Value below requirement | Capacity, IPLV or noise short | Re-run the selection with a 3–5% margin |
| Table and report disagree | Bid says 6.3, report says 5.9 | Use the report value; change the model if needed |
| Reference mismatch | Reference model differs from offered model | Use only same-model references |
| Authorization or service missing | No manufacturer letter, no local support | Provide the exact forms and the local address |
| Price above ceiling | Technical score high, commercial rejected | Ask the budget range, offer tiered configurations |
Technical score and price score are separate, but they interact. A bid that is technically strong and commercially high can lose to a slightly weaker but cheaper offer. Read the scoring weights before choosing the model: a 3% capacity margin that costs 12% more may lose more points than it gains. Where the tender allows, offer a base model and an optional higher-efficiency model, so the evaluator can see the trade without rejecting the base bid.
4. The supply boundary
Performance is only half the contract. The other half is who supplies what. Write seven boundaries into the bid: the unit and starter panel; vibration isolation and foundation; first refrigerant and oil charge; water-side valves and strainers; BMS interface (dry contact or gateway); transport, unloading and rigging; commissioning, training and documentation.
The two most common omissions are the starter panel and the BMS gateway. If the panel is “by others”, the bid must state the cable, breaker and control interface. If the gateway is “by others”, the protocol and point list must be defined. Otherwise the gap becomes a variation order.
5. Commercial evidence
References should include the contract page, the model and the acceptance certificate. A list of project names without models is not evidence.
Service should name the local office, the resident technician, the spare-parts location and the response time. “24-hour response” without an address is a slogan.
Warranty should separate the whole unit, the compressor and the wear parts, and state whether water-quality damage is covered. A two-year warranty that excludes the heat exchanger is narrower than the headline.
6. A final check
Print the response table, then read it with the catalog and the test reports open. For every row, point to the page that proves the value. If you cannot point to it, rewrite the row. This is slower than copying the catalog, and it is the step that keeps the bid alive.
Common questions
Can a response table say “meets” for a star clause?
No. A star clause needs a value, a condition and an evidence page. “Meets” without data can be treated as non-responsive.
Is a positive deviation always good?
Not always. A much larger capacity can leave the chiller at low load, and a larger footprint or water resistance can affect the plant. Keep deviations in the 3–8% range and explain them.
How many negative deviations are allowed?
Check the tender. A common limit is three, and a star clause allows none. Count before submission.
What if the test report is for an older model?
Use the report value or change the offered model. A manufacturer’s “equivalent” letter is weaker than a report for the exact model.
Should the bid include the starter panel?
If the tender includes it, yes. If not, state the interface and the cable and breaker requirements so the gap is visible.
What is the most common technical rejection?
A table that cannot be traced to a report, followed by a star clause answered with “meets”.
What table columns?
Duty, condition, guarantee, evidence and deviation. Five columns make the response auditable. A narrative paragraph hides the gap.
What scores?
Compliance, evidence quality and risk. A low price with no evidence is not a low risk. Score the evidence first.
Further technical reading
- Chiller Acceptance Standards
- GB 19577-2024 Chiller Efficiency
- Water Chiller Sizing
- Chiller Plant BAS Integration
LONGCOM can build the response table, align the offered model with the test report and define the supply boundary before the bid is submitted. For a tender review, contact 400-878-0280 or 13002001280.
Related reading
Chiller Factory Acceptance Test · Chiller Green Factory Upgrade · Chiller Retrofit Payback