Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Drying · Reduction · Integrated

Sludge Dryer Dehumidification Ratio Explained

A sludge dryer datasheet says “dehumidification ratio 3.2”. A buyer reads it as an efficiency ratio, compares it with another supplier’s “COP 4.5”, and concludes that the second machine is more efficient. The comparison is wrong: the two numbers have different units and different boundaries. One measures water removed per unit of electricity; the other measures cooling delivered per unit of electricity.

The dehumidification ratio — sometimes written SMER, for specific moisture extraction rate — is the most useful single number for a sludge dryer, provided it is converted correctly and the boundary conditions are stated. It is also easy to misuse: the most common error overestimates electricity by more than 40%.

1. Definition: the ratio and its reciprocal

Dehumidification ratio is the mass of water removed per unit of electrical energy, in kg/kWh. Specific energy is the electrical energy per unit mass of water, in kWh/kg. They are reciprocals.

A ratio of 3.2 means 3.2 kg water/kWh. The specific energy is 1 ÷ 3.2 = 0.3125 kWh/kg, or 312.5 kWh per metric ton of water. A datasheet that quotes “300 kWh/t” is quoting a ratio of 3.33.

Ratio (kg/kWh) Specific energy (kWh/kg) Specific energy (kWh/t water)
2.5 0.400 400
3.0 0.333 333
3.3 0.303 303
3.6 0.278 278
4.0 0.250 250

Use this table to check a claim. A “ratio 4.5” implies 222 kWh/t water. In conventional low-temperature drying, that is almost unattainable unless the boundary is unusually favorable — very dry feed, very low ambient, or a number that is not a measured value.

2. The link to COP is indirect

The energy path is: the compressor consumes W; the evaporator absorbs Q for dehumidification; the condenser rejects Q + W to the drying air. The ratio depends on how much of the cooling is used for condensation and how much energy is needed per kilogram of water.

Evaporating and condensing 1 kg of water from sludge requires about 2,500 kJ, including the latent heat of about 2,400 kJ plus wetting and sensible heat. That is 0.69 kWh. The theoretical relation is:

Ratio = COP × (share of cooling used for condensation) ÷ 0.69

A COP of 4.0 with all cooling used for condensation gives 4.0 ÷ 0.69 = 5.8. Real machines do not reach that because 25–40% of the cooling is sensible (it lowers air temperature without producing condensate), 10–15% of the power is fans, pumps and conveyors, and the evaporator-to-air temperature difference adds irreversibility. After those deductions, a real ratio of 2.8–3.6 corresponds to a COP of 3.5–4.5.

System COP Theoretical ratio, all cooling Real ratio at 55% useful cooling
3.0 4.35 2.4
3.5 5.07 2.8
4.0 5.80 3.2
4.5 6.52 3.6

This is why a “ratio above 4.5” deserves a question. It may be a laboratory value at a favorable boundary, or it may count condenser heat recovery twice.

3. Boundary conditions can change the number by 40%

The ratio is not a fixed property of the machine. It is the performance at a particular feed, product, air temperature and ambient.

Outlet moisture. The last part of drying is the hardest. From 40% to 30%, surface water is nearly gone and internal diffusion controls; the ratio may fall by 15%.

Air temperature. Higher air temperature speeds evaporation, but it also raises the condensing temperature and lowers COP. From 50 °C to 60 °C, the ratio typically falls by 8%.

Ambient temperature. The dryer’s heat comes from a closed loop, but the loop loses more heat to a cold workshop. At 5 °C instead of 25 °C, the loss is 8–12%, and the ratio falls by about 10%.

Organic content. From 50% to 70% organic matter, the water is more bound and the ratio falls by about 12%.

Boundary change Effect on ratio
Outlet 40% → 30% −15%
Air 50 → 60 °C −8%
Workshop 25 → 5 °C −10%
Organic 50 → 70% −12%

Before comparing two machines, ask four questions: feed moisture, outlet moisture, air temperature and ambient temperature. Without all four, the ratio cannot be compared across suppliers.

4. Use the ratio to back-calculate capacity and cost

Capacity. A 100 kW unit with a 75 kW compressor and a ratio of 3.2 removes 75 × 3.2 = 240 kg water/h, or 5.76 t/d. If the feed is 80% and the product 30%, each metric ton of wet sludge removes (0.80 − 0.30) ÷ (1 − 0.30) = 0.714 t water. The unit therefore processes 5.76 ÷ 0.714 = 8.07 t wet sludge/d.

Cost. For 14.3 t water/d and a ratio of 3.2, electricity is 14,300 ÷ 3.2 = 4,469 kWh/d. At 0.65 CNY/kWh, the daily cost is 2,905 CNY. For 20 t wet sludge, that is 145 CNY/t.

Item Formula Result
Hourly water removal compressor kW × ratio 240 kg/h
Daily water removal 240 × 24 5.76 t/d
Wet sludge, 80→30% 5.76 ÷ 0.714 8.07 t/d
Energy per metric ton water 1,000 ÷ 3.2 312 kWh
Electricity per metric ton wet sludge 0.714 × 312 × 0.65 145 CNY

This calculation also checks a quotation. If a supplier offers 20 t/d with a 90 kW unit, the hourly water removal is 90 × 3.2 = 288 kg, or 6.9 t/d. At 0.714 t water per metric ton of wet sludge, that is 9.7 t/d, not 20 t/d. Either the 20 t/d is at a different moisture basis, or the ratio is overstated.

5. The common error: treating wet metric tons as water metric tons

A buyer calculates: 20 t/d, ratio 3.2, so electricity = 20,000 ÷ 3.2 = 6,250 kWh/d. That treats “metric ton of wet sludge” as “metric ton of water” and overestimates by more than 40%.

The correct calculation first finds the water removed: 20 t at 80% to 30% removes 14.3 t water, so electricity = 14,300 ÷ 3.2 = 4,469 kWh/d. The difference is 1,781 kWh/d; at 0.65 CNY/kWh, 1,158 CNY/d, or about 423,000 CNY/year at 365 days (382,000 CNY at 330 operating days).

The denominator is always water, not sludge. Keep that in mind and the largest source of error disappears.

6. Five engineering factors that move the real ratio

Heat-transfer area. If the evaporator cannot bring the air below its dew point, water does not condense and the ratio falls. Undersized evaporator area is the most common cost reduction in low-priced machines.

Air flow and velocity. Too little flow gives poor heat transfer; too much gives a face velocity above 3 m/s, which carries droplets back into the material. Design velocity is 2–2.5 m/s.

Condensate drainage. A shallow drain pan or a missing trap lets condensate re-evaporate. The loss can reach 5%.

Purge and fresh-air ratio. A fully closed loop has a high ratio, but once the air is saturated the drying rate falls. A small purge is needed; each 10% of purge adds about 6% heat loss.

Bed thickness and turning. A thick bed dries on the surface while the inside stays wet; poor turning causes agglomeration. Neither factor appears on the datasheet, but both change the site result.

7. Three procurement rules

Do not compare ratios across suppliers unless the boundaries match. Require a test report at the same feed, product, air temperature and ambient. If the supplier cannot provide one, run a pilot with your own sludge.

Write the ratio into the performance clause. Define a 72-hour test: feed mass, feed moisture, product moisture, and kWh from a dedicated meter. If the measured ratio is below the guarantee, apply the agreed penalty.

Budget in kWh per metric ton of water, not in ratio. “300 kWh/t water” is easier to read and harder to misapply than “ratio 3.33”.

Common questions

Is a ratio of 3.5 good or bad?

It is normal-to-good for low-temperature drying. Standard machines are 2.8–3.3; well-designed heat recovery and generous evaporator area reach 3.5–3.8. Above 4.5, verify the test conditions.

Can the ratio be compared directly with an air-conditioner COP?

No. The units differ: kg water/kWh versus kW cooling/kW power. Convert by multiplying by the latent heat and the share of cooling used for condensation.

Why is the datasheet ratio higher than the site measurement?

Datasheets are often at 25 °C ambient, 78% feed and 40% product. A site at 5 °C with a 30% product can be 20% lower. Both factors compound.

Does the ratio fall over time?

Yes. Fouled heat exchangers, dirty coils and falling air flow reduce it by 5–10% a year. A cleaning program keeps the loss within 5%.

How does a heat-pump dryer compare with a steam dryer?

A steam dryer does not use electricity; the comparison is kg steam per kg water, typically 1.0–1.3. To compare, convert the steam price to an equivalent electricity cost.

Can one ratio decide whether a machine is good?

No. It is one indicator. Also check throughput stability, outlet moisture control and the degradation after three years. A single number can mislead.

What does the ratio mean?

Kilograms of water removed per kWh of electricity. It is not kW cooling per kW power. Convert it to kWh per metric ton before comparing.

How do I convert to kWh/t?

Divide 1,000 by the ratio in kg/kWh. A ratio of 4 kg/kWh is 250 kWh/t. State the boundary and the moisture.

Related reading

Sludge throughput calculation · Sludge-dryer capacity shortfall · Sludge-dryer efficiency loss · Sludge-dryer energy and operating cost

Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can convert dehumidification ratio to kWh per metric ton of water, align the boundary conditions and write a 72-hour performance test. For project data, call 400-878-0280 or 13002001280.

Related reading

Dehumidification psychrometrics · Dryer heat balance · Sludge dryer energy cost