A site visit is expensive for both sides. The buyer prepares a file, the supplier sends an engineer, and the day is spent measuring a feed that may not be representative. The questions below are the ones that make the visit useful, arranged in the order a buyer should ask them.
They are not a script for negotiating a discount. They are the questions that decide whether the quotation is comparable.
Before the visit: the file to bring
Bring the last three months of feed records: daily tonnage, moisture, and any upstream upset. Bring the water analysis, the disposal contract and the receiving facility’s acceptance limit. Bring the site plan with the proposed dryer location, the power capacity, the drain and the odor discharge point.
If the plant has a current dryer, bring its operating log: kWh, condensate, downtime and the last maintenance report. A log is more valuable than a description, because it shows the real load pattern.
Six process questions
1. What is the feed moisture, and how was it measured? A number without a method is a guess. Ask for wet basis, oven method and the sample date. A 5-point difference changes the evaporative load by 20–30%.
2. What is the target moisture, and who receives the product? The receiving facility’s limit is the real target. Thermal co-incineration may accept 30–40%; composting may want 55–65%; landfill may require lower. Do not over-dry for a route that does not need it.
3. What is the daily and hourly feed? A 10 t/d plant that runs 8 h needs a different machine from a 10 t/d plant that runs 24 h. The hourly rate, not the daily total, sizes the machine.
4. What is the organic fraction and the calorific value? This decides the final use, the odor control and the auxiliary fuel. A high organic sludge may support co-incineration; a mineral sludge may not.
5. What are the chloride, oil and grit levels? These decide the material, the liner and the cleaning interval. A high chloride sludge with 304 stainless is a corrosion claim waiting to happen.
6. Is the sludge hazardous? Drying does not change the hazardous property. The disposal route and the permit must be confirmed before the dryer selection.
Four commercial questions
7. What is included in the quoted capacity? Feed rate, feed moisture, target moisture and running hours. A quote that says “10 t/d” without these cannot be compared with another quote.
8. What is the guaranteed specific energy, and at what conditions? Ask for kWh/kg water at the design feed, ambient and target. A guarantee without conditions is a brochure number.
9. What is the scope: dryer only, or the full line? Feeding, discharging, odor control, condensate treatment, installation and commissioning are often excluded. Compare the total installed cost, not the machine price.
10. What is the spare-part and service package? Belt, bearings, seals, fans and sensors. Ask for the recommended spares and the response time. A machine with a 4-week belt lead time is a production risk.
Three acceptance questions
11. How will the performance test be run? The test should use the buyer’s sludge, the agreed moisture, a stable ambient and a measured power meter. It should run long enough to reach steady state, not a 30-minute demonstration.
12. What is the acceptance tolerance? A common tolerance is ±5% on capacity and ±10% on specific energy, with a defined correction for feed moisture. The tolerance should be in the contract, not discussed after the test.
13. What happens if the feed changes? A dryer selected for 80% feed may be short at 85%. Ask for the capacity at the wettest expected feed and the correction method. A 10% margin is common; a 0% margin is a promise, not a design.
| Question | Why it matters | Weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| Feed moisture | Sets the evaporative load | “About 80%” with no method |
| Target moisture | Sets the dryer and the route | “As dry as possible” |
| Hourly rate | Sets the machine size | Daily total only |
| Specific energy | Sets the operating cost | kWh/t product, not kWh/kg water |
| Scope | Sets the total cost | Dryer price only |
What to measure on site
Measure the feed moisture with a portable meter and take a sample for the laboratory. Measure the feed rate over a known period, not from the press display. Measure the available power capacity and the distance to the drain. Measure the noise and the odor at the nearest sensitive point.
If the site has an existing dryer, measure its kWh and condensate for a shift. The numbers are the best benchmark for the new machine. A supplier who cannot explain why the existing machine uses more energy than the guarantee is not ready to guarantee a new one.
Red flags
A quote that guarantees capacity without a feed moisture; a specific energy without a condition; a scope that excludes odor and condensate; a material that ignores chloride; a performance test that uses the supplier’s own sludge. Any one of these makes the comparison unreliable.
A low price with a short spare list is not necessarily a bargain. The five-year cost includes the belt, the cleaning, the downtime and the energy. Ask for the five-year consumables and service estimate in writing.
Boundary
These questions are for a low-temperature heat-pump dryer. A high-temperature or a direct-fired dryer needs additional questions on fire risk and volatiles. A hazardous-waste project needs a regulatory review before the commercial negotiation.
Common questions
What should I bring to a dryer site visit?
Three months of feed records, water analysis, disposal contract, site plan, power capacity and the existing dryer log. The log is the best benchmark.
What moisture basis should the quote use?
Wet basis, with the method. A wet-basis 30% is about 43% on a dry basis; mixing the two is a common dispute.
Why is kWh/kg water better than kWh/t product?
The water number is independent of the feed and product moisture, so it can be compared across sites. The product number hides the effect of the target moisture.
What acceptance tolerance is normal?
About ±5% on capacity and ±10% on specific energy, with a correction for feed moisture. Put it in the contract before the test.
Should the performance test use my sludge?
Yes. A test on the supplier’s reference sludge does not prove the machine will meet the guarantee on your feed.
What is the biggest hidden cost?
Odor and condensate treatment, plus the spare parts and downtime. A dryer price that excludes these is not the installed cost.
What site data should I prepare?
Feed moisture, target moisture, hourly rate, operating hours, power, water, drainage, slab and access. A photo of the feed and a sample help. Without these, the quote is a catalog number, not a project.
How do I compare quotes with different scope?
Normalize to the same feed, product, capacity and boundary. Check whether power, installation, commissioning, spares and warranty are included. Compare delivered cost per metric ton of water evaporated, not the headline price.
Further technical reading
For the seven inputs, see Seven Inputs Before a Sludge-Dryer Guarantee. For the kWh guarantee, see A kWh Guarantee Needs Three Meters. For the heat balance, see Where the Heat Goes. For the first ten minutes of an alarm, see Sludge-Dryer Alarm: The First Ten Minutes.
Related reading
Seven inputs for a guarantee · Sludge dryer sizing · Sludge dryer energy cost