A coal-to-electric retrofit that combines space heating and domestic hot water in one heat-pump plant looks simple on a sales sheet: one machine, two services, less space. In practice, most failures come from the same place — two loads with different temperatures and different peak times competing for the same capacity on the coldest days.
Space heating is continuous, low-temperature and weather-dependent. Hot water is intermittent, high-temperature and concentrated in the morning and evening. If the plant is sized on the sum of both peaks, it is oversized for most of the year. If it is sized on the average, one service will fail during a cold snap.
1. The two load profiles
| Item | Space heating | Domestic hot water |
|---|---|---|
| Supply temperature | 35–45 °C, floor heating or fan coil | 55–60 °C |
| Operation | Continuous, follows outdoor temperature | Intermittent, morning and evening peaks |
| Peak time | 04:00–06:00, coldest | 19:00–22:00 |
| Variation | Within 30% through the day | Peak 3–5 times the average |
| Storage | Building mass, buffer tank | Hot-water tank |
| Failure effect | Room temperature falls, tolerated for hours | No hot water, immediate complaint |
The important row is the peak time. Heating peaks before dawn; hot water peaks in the evening. That separation is what makes a combined plant possible. It does not mean the loads never overlap: during a cold snap the heating runs near full output at night, and if the hot-water tank is also cold, neither service gets enough.
The answer is not a larger unit. It is a larger hot-water tank and an explicit priority logic. Size the tank at about 1.5 times daily hot-water demand, charge it during the low-tariff window, and let the unit concentrate on heating during the evening peak.
2. Calculate both loads separately
Heating load. Use a W/m² index and correct for the envelope. A new building at the 65% energy-efficiency standard is 35–45 W/m²; a typical rural retrofit is 45–60 W/m²; a non-insulated brick house is 70–100 W/m²; a single-story house with 3.5 m ceilings can reach 100–120 W/m². The last row is the one most often underestimated.
For a 120 m² non-insulated single-story house at 110 W/m², the heating load is 13.2 kW. The same area at 45 W/m² is 5.4 kW — a factor of 2.4. Sizing on the efficient figure guarantees a cold house.
Hot-water load. For three people at 50 L/person/day, heated from 5 °C to 55 °C: 3 × 50 × 50 × 4.187 ÷ 3,600 = 8.7 kW·h/d. Add 15% for pipe and tank losses, about 10 kW·h/d. A 3 kW heat pump can produce that in four hours; the real constraint is delivering 150 L at 55 °C during the morning peak, which requires a 200 L tank.
For the example, select a 14–16 kW unit, a 200 L hot-water tank and a 100 L buffer. The hot-water load adds about 2.5 kW when averaged over the day; the unit is sized by the heating load, with the tank carrying the hot-water peak.
3. Cold-weather output is not the nominal figure
Air-source capacity falls with outdoor temperature. A unit rated at 16 kW at 7 °C may deliver the following:
| Outdoor temperature | Capacity | COP | Share of nominal |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 °C | 16.0 kW | 3.6 | 100% |
| 0 °C | 14.2 kW | 3.0 | 89% |
| −7 °C | 12.0 kW | 2.4 | 75% |
| −12 °C | 10.2 kW | 2.0 | 64% |
| −20 °C | 7.6 kW | 1.5 | 48% |
Design outdoor temperatures vary widely: Beijing about −7.6 °C, Shijiazhuang −8 °C, Shenyang −16.8 °C, Harbin −24 °C, Hohhot −19 °C. A unit selected for −12 °C will not carry Harbin; one selected for −24 °C will be 40% oversized in Beijing.
The practical rule is to select for the local design temperature and accept a backup source for the few coldest days. Electric resistance, a biomass stove or the existing coal stove can run for less than 100 h/year with little effect on the annual bill.
4. Three hydraulic arrangements
Single tank with a three-way valve. Heating and hot water share one tank and switch by valve. It is the cheapest and simplest, but the temperature swings and the heating circuit can be hit by 55 °C water. Use it only for small areas with floor heating and low comfort requirements.
Twin tanks. A heating buffer and a hot-water tank are separated; the unit switches between them, with hot water priority. This is the mainstream choice for coal-to-electric retrofits. It costs a few thousand CNY more and is noticeably more comfortable.
Plate heat exchanger isolation. The heating side runs through a plate exchanger; the hot-water side is heated directly. The two sides have independent water quality and pressure, which suits old systems with cast-iron radiators or poor water quality.
The hot-water priority logic must specify three things. First, when the hot-water tank is 5 K below setpoint, the unit pauses heating and serves hot water. Second, the pause has a time limit — 60 minutes — after which the unit must return to heating. Third, during the low-tariff window, charge the hot-water tank to 60 °C so it does not compete in the evening.
5. Freeze protection and defrost water
In the north, freeze damage is the most common failure. Insulate outdoor pipes and the unit water circuit to 30–50 mm, depending on the local extreme. For houses that are empty for long periods, use glycol or an anti-freeze mode that starts the pump and unit when water falls below 5 °C.
Defrost water is 20–50 L/d. Slope the drain pan, fit a drain-pipe heater, and discharge to a soakaway or ditch, never against the wall. If it freezes at the base, it can lift or crack the unit.
Power failures are common on rural feeders. When the pump stops, water in the outdoor circuit is static; at −5 °C, a few hours can split a pipe. Fit a solenoid valve that drains the outdoor circuit on power failure, or a controller with battery-backed circulation.
6. Running cost, with the tariff stated
For the 120 m² non-insulated house, 120 days, average load factor 0.5, heating load 13.2 kW: annual heat = 13.2 × 24 × 120 × 0.5 = 19,008 kW·h.
| Source | Annual energy | Unit price | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coal stove | 5.1 t | 700 CNY/t | 3,570 CNY |
| Gas boiler | 2,118 m³ | 2.8 CNY/m³ | 5,930 CNY |
| Direct electric | 20,008 kW·h | 0.50 CNY/kWh | 10,004 CNY |
| Heat pump, seasonal COP 2.6 | 7,311 kW·h | 0.50 CNY/kWh | 3,656 CNY |
The heat pump is roughly level with coal, about 40% cheaper than gas and about 60% cheaper than direct electric. At 0.55 CNY/kWh, however, the annual cost rises to 4,021 CNY and becomes more expensive than coal. The tariff must be stated: coal-to-electric tariff, peak/off-peak periods, and any capacity charge.
Insulation changes the result more than the equipment. Reducing the heat index from 110 to 60 W/m² halves the annual cost to about 2,000 CNY. In a coal-to-electric program, insulation often has a better return than a larger or more expensive heat pump.
Related reading
Heat pump versus gas boiler cost · Cold-climate heat-pump selection · Heat-pump water piping layout · Frost and defrost in winter operation
Longcom Environmental Protection Equipment Co., Ltd. can calculate the two loads, select the cold-weather capacity, and design the twin-tank hydraulic arrangement with freeze protection. For project data, call 400-878-0280 or 13002001280.
Frequently asked questions
What changes when coal heating is replaced?
The heat source becomes electricity, so the electrical service, metering and control sequence change. Heating is continuous and low-temperature; hot water is intermittent and higher-temperature. The two loads should be separated, not pooled into one tank.
How is the coldest day handled?
Size the heat pump for the design heat loss at the local design temperature, or use a hybrid with a backup boiler or electric heater. Do not size only on the average winter temperature. Check the unit’s capacity table at the design ambient.
Why separate heating and hot-water tanks?
Heating runs at lower temperature for long periods; domestic hot water needs a higher setpoint and a Legionella cycle. A single tank can force the heat pump to a higher temperature than heating needs, lowering efficiency.
What electrical work is needed?
Service capacity, cable, switchgear, metering and grounding. A retrofit may need a transformer upgrade. Confirm the available capacity before ordering the heat pump; this is often the real project constraint.
How is the existing system reused?
Keep the distribution, radiators or floor loops if they can run at the heat pump temperature. Flush the old system, add antifreeze if needed, and check valves and pumps. A high-temperature retrofit may need emitter changes.
Are incentives available?
Depends on the region and the fuel replaced. Confirm eligibility and metering requirements before assuming a subsidy. Build the payback without the incentive first, then add it as upside.
How should commissioning be sequenced?
Pressure-test, flush, fill, vent, check flow, then run the heat pump at part load. Verify the backup changeover, freeze protection and Legionella cycle. Record the design and actual temperatures.
What are the main risks?
Underestimating electrical capacity, oversized heat pump at low load, poor water quality, and a backup that does not start. Address each in design and commissioning, not after the first cold snap.
Related reading
Heat pump vs gas boiler cost · PV and heat pump hybrid · Heat-pump BAS integration