Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Industrial cooling · Process

Screw Compressor Control: Slide Valve or VFD

A screw compressor is the default choice for water chillers from about 30 to 500 RT. It is compact, tolerant of liquid slugging and efficient at part load. The part-load behavior, however, depends on how the capacity is controlled. A slide valve and a variable-speed drive are not interchangeable; they solve different problems and have different limits.

This article explains the compression cycle, the meaning of Vi, and the trade-off between slide-valve and VFD control. The numbers are indicative; the manufacturer’s part-load curve is the authority for a project.

Four stages, one pair of rotors

A screw compressor has a male and a female rotor. The gas is trapped in a cavity between the rotors and the casing, carried from the suction port to the discharge port, and compressed as the meshing teeth reduce the cavity volume. There is no reciprocating valve, so the flow is smooth and the machine can run at high speed.

Stage Rotor position Volume What happens
Suction Cavity open to the suction port Increasing Gas enters
Transfer Cavity closed Constant Gas is carried toward discharge
Compression Teeth mesh into the cavity Decreasing Pressure rises
Discharge Cavity open to the discharge port Minimum High-pressure gas leaves

Vi is built into the rotor

The internal volume ratio, Vi, is the cavity volume at the start of compression divided by the volume at the discharge port. Common values are 2.6, 3.6 and 5.0. A low Vi suits a low pressure ratio, such as high evaporating temperature and low condensing temperature. A high Vi suits a low evaporating temperature or a high condensing temperature.

If the Vi is too low for the operating pressure ratio, the gas reaches discharge pressure before the port opens and the compressor over-compresses, wasting power. If the Vi is too high, the gas is under-compressed and the discharge port opens early, causing a pressure pulsation. A fixed Vi is therefore a compromise across the operating envelope.

Slide valve: variable volume, fixed speed

The slide valve moves along the rotor axis and opens a bypass path back to suction. At full load it is closed; as it opens, part of the cavity is bypassed and the effective capacity falls. The control is stepless from about 10% to 100%, driven by oil pressure and positioned by the controller.

The slide valve is robust and inexpensive, and it maintains a high gas velocity through the compressor at low load, which helps oil return. Its weakness is that the Vi remains fixed. At low load and a high pressure ratio, the machine can operate away from its best internal compression point.

VFD: variable speed, fixed Vi

A variable-speed drive changes the rotor speed and therefore the flow. The capacity range is typically 25–100%, and the compressor can stay at a favorable Vi because the pressure ratio changes less when the speed is reduced. The motor, bearings and oil pump must be designed for variable speed; a standard motor retrofitted with a VFD may not have adequate cooling at low speed.

The VFD adds cost and electrical losses, but it can reduce the compressor power at part load and lower the starting current. It also avoids the slide valve’s bypass losses. In a plant that spends most of its hours below 60% load, the VFD is often the better choice.

Feature Slide valve VFD
Capacity range About 10–100% About 25–100%
Vi Fixed Fixed, but pressure ratio varies less
Part-load efficiency Good Better at low load
Starting current Star-delta or soft starter Low, soft start
Cost Lower Higher
Oil return Reliable at low load Needs a speed-aware oil system

Part-load numbers

The source data for a 100 kW screw compressor shows the difference. At 100% load, both controls are near a COP of 5.0. At 50%, a fixed-speed machine using start-stop or throttling may fall to about 3.2, while a slide-valve machine holds about 4.0. A VFD can be slightly better again, depending on the Vi and the condenser temperature.

These figures are illustrative. A real project should use the manufacturer’s curve at the actual condensing and evaporating temperatures, not a single IPLV value. The IPLV rating is a weighted test, not a guarantee at every hour.

Choose by load profile

If the chiller runs most of the year near 70–90% load, the slide valve is adequate and the lower capital cost may win. If the load spends 2,000 hours below 50%, the VFD’s low-load efficiency and soft start are worth the premium. If the condenser water temperature is low for much of the year, the pressure ratio is lower and the Vi mismatch is smaller, which reduces the VFD advantage.

Also check the minimum load. A screw compressor at 20% load may be stable with a slide valve but inefficient. Two smaller machines may be better than one large VFD machine if the load rarely rises above 40%. The control choice cannot fix a bad machine count.

Common questions

What is Vi in a screw compressor?

Vi is the internal volume ratio: the cavity volume at the start of compression divided by the volume at the discharge port. It is fixed by the rotor geometry and should match the operating pressure ratio.

Is a VFD always more efficient than a slide valve?

No. At high load the difference is small, and the VFD adds electrical and capital cost. The advantage grows at low load and low pressure ratio, especially where the machine spends many hours below 50%.

Can a standard motor be retrofitted with a VFD?

Not safely without checking the motor’s insulation, cooling and bearing current. A variable-speed compressor needs a motor designed for the speed range and an oil system that works at low speed.

Why does a screw compressor lose efficiency at low load?

The fixed Vi may no longer match the pressure ratio, and the slide valve bypasses gas. At very low load the gas velocity and oil return also become marginal.

Should I choose one large VFD screw or two smaller screws?

Compare the annual load profile. Two smaller machines can stage better below 40% load; one large VFD is simpler but may run inefficiently at very low load. The machine count is a separate decision from the control type.

Does IPLV prove the part-load performance?

No. IPLV is a weighted rating at specified conditions. It is useful for comparison, but the project should check the part-load curve at its own condenser and evaporator temperatures.

When is a VFD better than a slide valve?

When the load varies widely and part-load hours dominate. A VFD turns down smoothly and avoids blowback, but it costs more and needs a compatible compressor. A slide valve is simpler for stable loads.

How do I avoid oil carryover at low load?

Keep the minimum speed and run time, use the correct oil separator, and check the oil return. Low load reduces velocity and can leave oil in the lines. Do not run below the manufacturer’s limit.

Further technical reading

For compressor comparison, see Piston, Scroll or Screw Chillers. For screw versus centrifugal, see Screw versus Centrifugal Chillers. For COP and IPLV, see COP vs IPLV. For part-load selection, see Chiller Selection: Full-Load COP Is Not the Decision.

Related reading

Chiller expansion valves · Chiller plant group control · Centrifugal head-flow and minimum load