“The unit is short of gas — just top it up” is common advice in service rooms, and it hides a basic fact: a refrigeration circuit is sealed. Refrigerant is not consumed in normal operation. If the charge is low, there is a leak. Adding gas without repairing the leak guarantees that the unit will be low again, and while it is low the compressor runs at a higher discharge temperature and the oil degrades faster.
The correct order is: confirm the charge is low, find and repair the leak, then evacuate and charge. Skipping the first two steps is like adding water to a leaking bucket. This article explains the measurements, the leak-detection methods and the charging procedure for a water-cooled chiller.
Refrigerant work requires qualified personnel and recovery equipment. Follow the manufacturer’s manual and local regulations.
1. Confirm low charge with four measurements
Do not diagnose from “it does not cool”. Use four indications together.
Subcooling. Normal subcooling is about 3–6 K for a water-cooled unit and 4–8 K for an air-cooled unit. When charge is low, the condenser liquid level falls and the refrigerant flashes before the expansion valve; subcooling drops below 2 K and may go negative. Measure liquid-line temperature minus the saturated temperature at condensing pressure. This is the most sensitive and easiest indicator.
Evaporator approach. Approach is the chilled-water outlet temperature minus the evaporating temperature; normal is 1–2 K. Low charge lowers the evaporating pressure and raises the approach above 4 K. The approach also rises when the heat exchanger is fouled, so check the water-side ΔT as well.
Discharge temperature and current. Low charge increases suction superheat; discharge temperature can rise 15–25 K, while the reduced mass flow lowers compressor current. High discharge temperature is a direct cause of compressor damage; stop the unit if it exceeds the manufacturer’s limit.
Sight glass and liquid level. A flooded evaporator has a level gauge; a dry evaporator has a sight glass. Bubbles suggest flashing, but a failed subcooler or excessive liquid-line pressure drop can also cause bubbles. Do not rely on the sight glass alone.
A useful cross-check: low chilled-water flow also raises the approach and reduces capacity, but subcooling usually stays normal. If subcooling is normal and the approach is high, look at the water side first.
2. Leak detection: match the method to the leak size
Different leak rates need different methods. Using only one method can produce a false “no leak” conclusion.
A practical sequence is: nitrogen pressure test to prove a leak exists, electronic detector to locate it, and fluorescent dye to confirm a micro-leak.
Common leak points, roughly in order of frequency: flange gaskets (especially after a service reassembly), valve-stem packing (more likely on a valve that is never operated), safety-valve and rupture-disc connections, pressure-gauge and pressure-switch fittings, weld heat-affected zones, evaporator tube-sheet joints (more likely with poor water quality or high chloride), and the secondary seal of the charging valve.
A tube-sheet leak has a distinctive signature: when the chilled-water pressure is higher than the evaporating pressure, water enters the circuit. The makeup-water demand rises, system moisture increases, and the expansion valve may ice. This is not a “low charge” problem but a “water ingress” problem, and it is more serious. Pressure-test the water side and analyze a water sample.
3. Charging: three steps that cannot be skipped
Step 1 — repair and prove the repair. Re-pressure-test after the repair. Hold 24 hours and correct the result for temperature. Charging an unrepaired circuit is a temporary fix, not a repair.
Step 2 — evacuate. Pull the system to an absolute pressure of 133 Pa or lower and hold for one hour without rise. This proves both tightness and dryness. Residual moisture reacts with refrigerant oil to form acid, which attacks the motor windings — a common reason a “newly charged” compressor fails.
Step 3 — charge as liquid. Charge liquid from the condenser outlet or a dedicated charging port. Never pour liquid into the low-pressure side: liquid slugging can break a scroll, bend a connecting rod or damage the compressor. If low-side charging is unavoidable, use a proper throttling device and charge slowly as vapor.
Calculate the charge from the nameplate plus line allowance. For a 22 mm liquid line, an allowance of about 0.35 kg/m gives 17.5 kg for 50 m. A unit with a 180 kg nameplate charge would then need about 197.5 kg. Use the manufacturer’s line-charge table; the allowance varies with diameter.
While charging, watch high pressure, low pressure, subcooling and compressor current. Stop when subcooling returns to 4–5 K, current is near the nameplate value and the sight glass is clear. Run for 30 minutes and record the stable values as a baseline.
4. The cost of a 5% annual leak
Take a 500 kW water-cooled screw chiller with 180 kg of R134a, a 5% annual leak rate, an electricity price of CNY 0.65/kWh and 2,500 operating hours per year.
Annual leakage = 180 × 5% = 9 kg. The refrigerant cost is significant, and the labor and leak detection add more.
The larger cost is efficiency. At 10% low charge, COP may fall by 5–8%. At 500 kW, 2,500 h and a COP of 5.0, annual electricity is 250,000 kW·h. A 6% efficiency loss adds 15,000 kW·h, or about CNY 9,750/year. This cost is invisible because the unit still cools — it simply uses more electricity.
For a 5% leak rate, the annual energy and refrigerant cost usually exceeds the cost of a proper leak repair. That is the economic case for scheduled leak detection, not only the environmental case.
5. Compliance and recovery
Under the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol, hydrofluorocarbons are subject to phased reduction, and China has implemented a quota system. Two practical consequences:
Do not vent. During service, dismantling or disposal, recover refrigerant into a cylinder with recovery equipment. It may be reclaimed or sent to a licensed disposal facility.
R22 is legacy. Existing equipment may continue to operate, but recharge is constrained by quota, supply is tight and prices are high. New equipment may not use R22. For units older than about 10 years, compare replacement against continued recharge; replacement is often the better lifecycle choice.
Technicians must hold the appropriate qualification. Recovery machines, leak detectors and personal protective equipment are basic requirements. In a confined space, refrigerant displaces oxygen; R134a at high concentration also produces decomposition products if exposed to a flame.
6. Make leak detection a routine
Monthly: record subcooling, approach, discharge temperature and current. A slow, simultaneous drift suggests a chronic leak.
Quarterly: scan the known leak-point list with an electronic detector, focusing on flanges, valve stems and fittings.
Annually: nitrogen pressure test during the shutdown and calculate the annual leak rate. A rate above 3% should be a priority repair.
The value of trend data is early warning. By the time the unit “does not cool”, it may already be 20% low, and the compressor and oil have suffered. A 5% low charge is cheap to fix; a 20% low charge is not.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know the chiller is low on refrigerant?
Low suction pressure, low subcooling, high superheat, poor capacity and a warm suction line can indicate low charge. But these also occur with a restriction or a bad sensor. Confirm with a mass balance and a leak search before adding refrigerant.
What do subcooling and approach tell me?
Subcooling at the condenser outlet shows how much liquid is stacked. Low subcooling can mean undercharge. Approach (condensing temperature minus leaving water temperature) rises with fouling or non-condensables. Read both, not just pressure.
How do I locate a leak?
Use electronic leak detection at joints, flanges, Schrader valves, welds and coil ends. Pressure-test with dry nitrogen and a trace gas. Check the evaporator and condenser circuits separately. Repair, then evacuate and recharge by weight.
Can I charge liquid into a running system?
Charge liquid at the liquid line or with a throttling device, never into the suction of a running compressor. Use a scale and the nameplate charge. For blends, charge liquid to avoid fractionation. Do not guess by sight glass alone.
Why is evacuation important?
Moisture and non-condensables raise condensing pressure, corrode the system and can freeze at the expansion valve. Evacuate to the required micron level and hold a vacuum test. Skipping this hides the real leak and shortens compressor life.
Which refrigerants need different handling?
A2L refrigerants are mildly flammable and need charge limits, ventilation and leak detection. High-pressure refrigerants need compatible hoses and recovery cylinders. Never mix refrigerants or use the wrong oil.
How do I avoid false charge?
Weigh the charge, log subcooling and superheat at a stable condition, and compare with the manufacturer’s table. A sight glass can be clear when the charge is wrong. Treat a single reading as a clue, not a diagnosis.
What records should be kept?
Refrigerant type, nameplate charge, added charge, leak location, repair method, vacuum level and final subcooling. Regulations often require this log. It also shows whether a repeat leak is the same joint.
Related reading
Centrifugal chiller surge · Heat-pump frost and defrost · High-altitude chiller selection