Heat pumps · Chillers · Sludge drying systems
Industrial cooling · Process

Cooling Water Treatment: Scale, Corrosion and Biofilm

A water-cooled chiller rejects heat through a cooling tower. The moment the tower is open to the atmosphere, the cooling water becomes a concentrating machine: pure water leaves as vapor, while calcium, magnesium, chloride, sulphate and airborne dust stay behind. Without deliberate control, the loop moves from “water” to a thin chemical reactor that coats the condenser, corrodes the tubes and grows biofilm.

Water treatment is not a consumable added to make the water look clean. It is the set of controls that keeps heat transfer, tube life and compressor reliability inside their design envelope. Manufacturers increasingly exclude heat-exchanger damage caused by untreated water from warranty, so the treatment program is also a commercial protection.

1. The open loop concentrates everything

In a cooling tower, evaporation removes water but not dissolved solids. If evaporation is 1 m³/h and the system is operated at three cycles of concentration, the blowdown is about 0.5 m³/h and make-up about 1.5 m³/h. At five cycles, blowdown falls to 0.25 m³/h and make-up to 1.25 m³/h, but the salt concentration in the loop rises by about two-thirds relative to three cycles.

The relationship is simple: cycles of concentration = make-up conductivity ÷ blowdown conductivity. The operator chooses the cycles by setting blowdown; the water chemistry then decides whether those cycles are safe. Pushing cycles higher saves makeup water and chemical cost, but raises scaling and corrosion risk. The correct setpoint is the highest cycle count that still keeps the limiting parameter inside its envelope.

Airborne dust, makeup water hardness and tower drift add load that cannot be seen in a conductivity reading alone. A tower beside a road or a construction site can accumulate silt faster than a tower on a clean roof. That is why filtration and periodic basin cleaning belong in the same program as inhibitors.

2. Three failure modes

Mode Mechanism Visible symptom Consequence
Scale Calcium and magnesium salts precipitate on the hottest tube surface Condenser approach temperature rises; high-pressure trips Heat transfer falls, head pressure and energy rise, tubes can block
Corrosion Dissolved oxygen, chloride and acidic conditions attack steel and copper Iron or copper in water analysis; tube leaks; rust in basin Perforation, refrigerant loss, water in refrigerant circuit
Biofilm Bacteria and algae attach to wetted surfaces and trap silt Slimy deposits, odor, rising differential pressure Heat transfer loss, under-deposit corrosion, Legionella risk

The three interact. Scale provides a rough surface for biofilm; biofilm traps scale and creates anaerobic pockets where corrosion accelerates. Treating only one mode leaves the other two to feed on each other.

3. A water-quality envelope, not a single number

The following values are typical guidance for an open cooling loop. They are not universal limits: tube material, water source, operating temperature and local regulations all shift the envelope. Use them to start a conversation with a water-treatment supplier, not to replace a site-specific program.

Parameter Typical target Why it matters
pH 7.5–9.0 Low pH accelerates steel and copper corrosion; high pH favors calcium carbonate scale
Conductivity Below about 1,500 µS/cm Proxy for dissolved solids and cycles of concentration
Calcium hardness About 100–300 mg/L as CaCO₃ Too low is corrosive; too high scales at the condenser
Chloride Below about 300 mg/L for carbon steel Chloride drives pitting; titanium or higher-grade steel raises the limit
Suspended solids Below about 20 mg/L Solids settle in the basin and foul tube inlets
Total bacteria Below 10⁵ CFU/mL Biofilm precursor; Legionella control needs a separate risk plan

A reading inside the table is not a guarantee. A stable program looks at trends: conductivity creeping up after a blowdown valve sticks, chloride rising after a change in make-up source, or differential pressure climbing while flow stays constant. One sample is a photograph; a trend is a diagnosis.

4. What a treatment program contains

Scale inhibitor and dispersant. The inhibitor raises the solubility limit or interferes with crystal growth; the dispersant keeps small particles suspended so they leave with blowdown instead of settling on tubes.

Corrosion inhibitor. The chemistry must match the metallurgy. A program designed for carbon steel may not protect copper tubes, and a high-chloride water may need a different inhibitor or a different tube material.

Biocide. Use at least two compatible biocides in rotation, because a single biocide selects resistant populations. Dose on a schedule and verify with ATP or dip-slide counts, not by smell.

Filtration. A sidestream filter or a basin sweep keeps silt out of the condenser. It also reduces the biocide demand because biofilm has less food and less shelter.

Automatic blowdown. Control on conductivity, not on a fixed timer. A timer is blind to make-up quality and load; a conductivity controller responds to both.

Cleaning. Mechanical brushing or chemical cleaning when the approach temperature or differential pressure crosses a threshold. Cleaning without fixing the chemistry returns the fouling in weeks.

5. Legionella is a separate risk

Cooling towers create aerosols. If the water contains Legionella, drift can carry it to people nearby. The risk is not solved by a corrosion inhibitor; it needs a water-risk management plan: keep the basin clean, avoid dead legs and stagnant sections, use effective biocide, fit drift eliminators, and record inspections.

High-risk sites — hospitals, hotels, care homes and dense urban buildings — should treat Legionella control as a documented program with named responsibility, not as an occasional shock dose. A tower that is cleaned only when someone complains is already outside a defensible plan.

6. Monitoring, records and warranty

A practical routine is daily conductivity, pH and make-up volume; weekly inhibitor and biocide residuals; monthly hardness, chloride, suspended solids and bacteria; annual internal inspection of the condenser and tower. Keep the records with the chiller log, because warranty disputes turn on evidence.

If a condenser fails at three years with a documented history of high chloride and no blowdown control, the manufacturer has a strong case that the water caused the damage. If the same failure occurs with a complete treatment log, the conversation is different. Records are not paperwork; they are the boundary between a maintenance issue and a warranty claim.

Common questions

Is water treatment necessary if the makeup water is already soft?

Soft water reduces calcium scale but does not remove chloride, sulphate or dissolved oxygen. Soft water can still corrode and still grow biofilm. Treatment scope changes; the need does not disappear.

How often should the condenser be cleaned?

Clean on condition, not on a calendar. A rising condenser approach temperature, rising head pressure or a falling heat-transfer coefficient is the trigger. A well-treated loop may need annual cleaning; a neglected open tower may need it every six months.

Can we simply increase blowdown to solve everything?

More blowdown lowers salt concentration but wastes water and chemical. It does not remove biofilm or correct a mismatched inhibitor. Set blowdown to hold the limiting parameter, then fix the chemistry and filtration.

What is the most common cause of high condenser pressure?

In a water-cooled chiller, insufficient cooling water or fouled tubes. Check flow, tower fan and basin level first, then the condenser approach. Refrigerant overcharge is possible but less common.

Does a magnetic or electronic scale device replace chemicals?

It may reduce scaling in some circuits, but it does not provide corrosion inhibition or biological control. A device that claims to replace a complete program should be judged on independent test data for all three risks.

What records should be kept for warranty?

Make-up and blowdown volumes, conductivity, pH, inhibitor and biocide residuals, bacteria counts, cleaning dates and photos of the condenser before and after cleaning. A single sheet per month is enough if it is complete.

What three risks?

Scale, corrosion and biofilm. Each has a different control: inhibitor, biocide and filtration. Test the water, not the label.

How do I test the water?

Conductivity, pH, alkalinity, hardness and microbial count. Test at the basin and the return. A single sample is not a trend.

Related reading

LONGCOM can review cooling-water analysis, cycles of concentration, tube material and cleaning intervals as part of a chiller plant assessment. For a water-treatment review, contact 400-878-0280 or 13002001280.

Related reading

Evaporator cleaning · Chiller plant sensors · Water chiller sizing