A sludge-dryer tender is not a sales document. It is a comparison system: each bidder is asked to prove that a specific machine, at a specific duty, will meet a specific guarantee. The technical response therefore has to be traceable — clause by clause, value by value, evidence by evidence.
Most failed responses are not technically incapable. They lose points because a star-rated clause was answered with a general statement, the model in the capacity table differs from the model in the quotation, or the energy figure has no stated boundary. Reviewers cannot award what they cannot trace.
1. Start with the duty, not the equipment
Take a typical tender: 10 t/day of 80% moisture sludge, dried to 30%, 24 hours operation. The mass balance fixes the rest:
| Item | Value | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Dry solids | 2.0 t/day | 10 × (1 − 0.80) |
| Product at 30% | 2.86 t/day | 2.0 ÷ 0.70 |
| Water removed | 7.14 t/day | 10 − 2.86 |
| Hourly evaporation | 298 kg/h | 7,140 ÷ 24 |
| Specific energy at 0.35 kWh/kg water | 2,500 kWh/day | 7,140 × 0.35 |
| Average power | 104 kW | 2,500 ÷ 24 |
| Installed power at 1.25–1.35 × average | 130–140 kW | 104 × 1.25 to 1.35 |
These numbers become the spine of the response: capacity, evaporation, energy, installed power and utility consumption. Every later claim should be consistent with them. A bid that states 10 t/day but quotes a 250 kg/h evaporator is already inconsistent, before any technical evaluation.
2. Declare the boundary of the energy figure
Specific energy — kWh per kg of water evaporated — is the most compared number in a sludge-dryer tender, and the most easily distorted. The boundary must be written next to the value.
| Condition | Typical specific energy | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Ambient 20 °C, 80% to 30% | 0.34–0.36 kWh/kg water | Reference condition |
| Ambient 10 °C, same duty | 0.38–0.42 kWh/kg water | Lower evaporating temperature; defrost; more heat loss |
| Feed 60% to 30% | 0.45–0.50 kWh/kg water | Less water removed per metric ton; fixed losses spread over less evaporation |
| Main unit only, excluding auxiliaries | 10–15% lower | Fans, pumps, conveyors and controls excluded |
| Including all auxiliaries | Full figure | The number the owner actually pays for |
A bid that quotes 0.30 kWh/kg at 10 °C ambient and includes all auxiliaries is either a different machine or an error. Ask for the test condition, the boundary and the source. If the answer is a brochure page without a boundary, the number is not comparable.
3. The five disqualifiers
Star-rated clauses answered with a general statement. A clause marked with a star usually requires a specific value and evidence. “Meets the requirement” without a number is a non-response, not a partial response.
Model mismatch. The model in the capacity table, the model in the quotation, the model in the energy calculation and the model in the spare-parts list must be the same. A reviewer who finds two models will question the whole bid.
Performance evidence that does not match the duty. A reference plant at 5 t/day and 70% feed does not prove a 10 t/day, 80% feed machine. Provide a reference with the same order of evaporation and the same feed type.
Missing authorization or service commitment. A distributor without a manufacturer’s authorization, or a bid without a local service response time, is a commercial risk. Tenders often score this separately, and a missing document can be fatal.
Price omissions. Installation, commissioning, spare parts, training, taxes and freight left out of the price are not free; they reappear as claims. State the scope included and the items excluded.
The technical scope and the commercial scope must tell the same story. A simple matrix prevents the most common omissions:
| Scope item | Included | By others | Where stated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dryer, heat pump, controls | Supplier | — | Equipment schedule |
| Foundation and structural base | — | Civil contractor | Layout and load drawing |
| Installation and lifting | Supplier or installer | Site contractor | Commercial scope |
| Electrical supply to the main isolator | — | Electrical contractor | Electrical interface drawing |
| Compressed air and water supply | — | Site utilities | Utility schedule |
| Commissioning and training | Supplier | — | Service scope |
| Spare parts and warranty | Supplier | — | Commercial terms |
A missing row is an interface gap, and an interface gap becomes a claim. Mark “by others” explicitly rather than leaving the cell blank; a blank cell can be read as included by the bidder and excluded by the owner.
4. Write the deviation table correctly
A technical deviation table is not a place to hide differences. Use three states: positive, negative and none. Then give the tender value, the offered value, the condition and the page reference.
| Item | Tender requirement | Offered | Deviation | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Evaporation | ≥298 kg/h | 310 kg/h at 20 °C | Positive, +4.0% | Capacity table p. 12; test report p. 34 |
| Specific energy | ≤0.40 kWh/kg | 0.35 kWh/kg, all auxiliaries | Positive, −12.5% | Energy calculation p. 18 |
| Outlet moisture | ≤30% | ≤28% at design feed | Positive | Guarantee clause p. 22 |
| Installed power | ≤150 kW | 138 kW | Positive | Electrical schedule p. 26 |
The percentage should be calculated against the tender value, and the direction should be unambiguous. “+4.0%” means better than the requirement for capacity; “−12.5%” means lower than the limit for energy. State the convention at the top of the table, or the reviewer will read the signs differently.
5. The evidence package
Attach only what the clause asks for, but attach it in a way that can be found. A typical package contains: the capacity table at the specified feed and ambient, the energy calculation with boundary, the electrical load schedule, the utility schedule (water, compressed air, drain), the layout and foundation load, the control points list, the reference list with contactable sites, the warranty and service terms, and the spare-parts list with lead times.
Label each attachment with the clause number it supports. A 200-page brochure without clause references forces the reviewer to search, and a searched document is a scored-down document.
6. Before submission
Run four checks. First, every star-rated clause has a number and a page reference. Second, the model number is identical across all tables. Third, the energy boundary includes or excludes auxiliaries consistently. Fourth, the commercial scope matches the technical scope: if installation is excluded from the price, it must also be excluded from the schedule and the responsibility matrix.
Then ask someone who did not write the bid to find the model number and the specific energy in under one minute. If they cannot, the reviewer will not either.
Common questions
What if we cannot meet a star-rated parameter?
State the offered value and the deviation clearly. A transparent negative may still be evaluated; a vague answer is usually treated as non-responsive. Do not hide a gap in a general statement.
Is a lower specific energy always better?
Only at the same boundary and condition. A lower number that excludes fans and pumps is not comparable with a full-boundary figure. Compare the guaranteed figure and the test method.
Can we use a reference plant with a different feed?
It can support general experience, but it does not prove performance on this sludge. Provide at least one reference with a similar feed type and evaporation scale, and state the difference.
How should installation cost be handled?
State whether it is included, excluded or priced as an option. Installation is typically 15–25% of equipment value; leaving it out of the price does not remove the cost.
What is the most common scoring loss?
Not the technology, but the traceability: a number without a page reference, a model that changes between sections, or a star clause answered in general terms.
Should the warranty be in the technical or commercial volume?
Put the technical scope and response time in both, with a cross-reference. A warranty buried only in commercial terms is often missed by the technical reviewer.
What tender parameters matter?
Feed basis, moisture, capacity, energy, guarantee, scope and payment. A tender without these invites incomparable bids.
How do I compare bids?
Convert every bid to the same boundary and moisture. Compare the guarantee and the spare/service package, not the headline.
Related reading
- How to Size a Sludge Dryer
- Sludge Dryer Standards and Acceptance
- Sludge Dryer Commissioning
- Sludge Dryer Selection Mistakes
LONGCOM can build a tender response around the duty, the energy boundary and a clause-by-clause evidence table, and check the model and scope for consistency before submission. For tender support, contact 400-878-0280 or 13002001280.
Related reading
Seven inputs for a guarantee · Dryer FAT witness test · Dryer price factors